Mar Roxas is wrong: Politics WAS behind the SAF44 massacre in Mamasapano

In his so-called “True State of the Nation Address” (TSONA) delivered at the Cavite State University yesterday, Vice President Jejomar Binay dedicated a significant part of the speech to the memories of the Philippine National Police Special Action Force (PNP-SAF) troopers who were killed in a botched operation in Mamasapano, Mindanao.

Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) Secretary Mar Roxas today criticised Binay for politicising the tragedy.

“Limang taon siyang nasa Cabinete na pumapalakpak sa mga tinatawag niyang palpak ngayon. Pero, worst of all, pinulitika niya ang kabayanihan ng SAF 44,” Roxas said in a statement released hours after Binay’s counter-SONA on Monday, August 3.

(For 5 years, he was part of the Cabinet that he’s saying now is a failure. But worst of all, he politicized the heroism of the SAF 44.)


Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us.
Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider!
Learn more

Contrary to what Roxas is asserting, however, the massacre of these good officers of the SAF is a political matter. Indeed, it was President BS Aquino himself who made it political at its most fundamental levels. The fact that the operation — a police operation — was kept from Roxas himself who has direct accountability over the PNP is, itself, suspect.

That fact alone makes the SAF massacre political. But here’s more…

(1) The police operation was kept secret from the Philippine military in order not to compromise the on-going negotiations between the Philippine government and the terrorist Moro Islamic Liberation Front.

Putting hundreds of elite police commandos under an unacceptable level of risk because of on-going negotiations with an enemy force is obviously politically-motivated. President BS Aquino put the safety of his pet project right up there in priority with accomplishing the mission with minimal loss of police assets. Had the risk to BS Aquino’s BBL project in the operation been relegated to a secondary consideration (where it should have been), the mission could have been successfully accomplished and the PNP boys safely extracted from the field.

(2) Involvement of suspended PNP director Alan Purisima cannot be given a purely operational explanation.

On purely technical terms, nothing can justify including then-suspended Purisima in the management loop of the ill-fated Mamasapano operation. There was a clear command line underneath Purisima’s position in the PNP hierarchy that could have been followed. So why then was Purisima included and his say allowed to weigh heavily in the Mamasapano operation?

Because Alan Purisima is the President’s friend. In this instance, the politics behind the bizarre way the Mamasapano operation was managed is quite simple.

(3) President BS Aquino did not mention anything about the Mamasapano incident on his sixth and last State of the Nation Address.

President BS Aquino’s liberal use of videos and other communication approaches that made use of information cherry-picked to make him look good made his SONA unabashedly political in nature. It was not a speech to report on the true state of the nation. It was a speech to appeal for votes.

Therefore, President BS Aquino’s bald omission of the biggest negatives in his administration — the bungled Mamasapano operation that resulted in the loss of an appalling number of lives — was itself nothing short of a political decision. The BBL, which was the primary thing at stake in the decision to keep the Philippine military out of the planning loop of the Mamasapano operation involved billions of pesos in anticipated budget appropriations. As such, beyond its toll on the national morale, the BBL and Mamasapano’s impact on it was an exceedingly relevant item that should have been taken up in the SONA.

* * *

It is, indeed, unfortunate that unimaginable tragedy would be used as a chip in today’s political “debate”. The point is that it was President BS Aquino who set it up to be used so. And Mar Roxas, being Mar Roxas, would, of course, echo the sentiments of his powerful endorser. And that, Mr Roxas, is political.

[Photo courtesy Manila Bulletin.]

4 Replies to “Mar Roxas is wrong: Politics WAS behind the SAF44 massacre in Mamasapano”

  1. I’d expect SAF44 to continue popping up on the headlines of GRP every now then. I guess they will never be laid to rest until true justice is served. Our politicians will continue to just brush all these cases under the rug hoping time will let them fade into the deep recesses of our memories.

    I didn’t really support the ERAP presidency, but his simple downtoearth thinking would have been the more appropriate position to take: all out war on everyone holding a gun illegally in Mindanao. Why is Robin Padilla the only Muslim that had to serve time for illegal gun possession ? He should cry “unfair!!!”

  2. Mar Roxas knew about the Mamapasano operation. When the bungled operation turned into Tragedy. He distanced himself from it. This is called “political expediency” , at the worst level.

    Purisima, a crook, and a suspended policeman, should not had been in the operation, at all. What is he doing there , directing police officers?

    Now, Roxas and Aquino want the Tragedy and the Heroism of the 44 murdered Police Officers, Swept under the Rug. The ABS-CBN, propaganda machine of Aquino and Roxas, never even mention about their heroism. They are more of Heroes, than Ninoy Aquino, Jr.

    This is the “Achiles Heel” of the Roxas bid for Presidency. Mar Roxas cannot explain it; and cannot get away from it. It like a “Spectre of a Ghost” haunting Roxas and Aquino…

  3. Under the presidency of Manuel “Mar” Araneta Roxas II…

    The Failippines and the Failipinos will end up under a Sword of Damocles on a tightrope over the abyss.

    Remember people, it’s not what you look at that matters, it’s what you see.

  4. why Mar was not informed about the operation in masasapano? I don’t believe on that coz it will added to his gross incompetence and no win to 2016. He trying to resign . Pnoy will not allowed to let be lame alone. Mar was in the hard circle of Incompetent pnoy and he is one of the planer maybe at the back stage with the rest of KKK’s. Zero vote for LP and some NP/LP balimbings

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.