I watched Red Ollero’s Upclose and Personalan with Director Brian Galagnara, and I was not disappointed one bit.
Red’s jokes landed better than mine did. I made one about holding him up in the men’s washroom, and he overheard it. It would have been a bad idea anyway: Red is over six feet tall, and I’m pretty sure he could catch me and break my back just by sitting on me.
I won’t spoil everything that had me in stitches. You have to catch him live, as I did, delivering an absolutely bonkers performance. But two moments from his hour-and-a-half act stay with me.
| SUPPORT INDEPENDENT SOCIAL COMMENTARY! Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider! Learn more |
The first was the bit where he blanked out when Vice Ganda threw him a line. It was self-deprecating and painfully real, and it was also the funniest thing I’ve heard anyone say about meeting Vice Ganda in that situation.
The second was his long conversation with an audience member who edits porn videos for a living. The circumstances that led to the guy’s mother commenting on his work-from-home gig were way too much information, and the whole exchange was so unhinged that I couldn’t believe it was happening.
That made the weekend a high point. So I was a bit let down to see Red posting the typical aktibista Facebook stuff against the ASEAN summit. A man who can find the joke in blanking out on Vice Ganda can surely find a better one than “there’s no traffic in Ba Sing Se.”
On Monday afternoon, comedian Red Ollero posted a meme on his verified Facebook page: Joo Dee, the smiling government guide from *Avatar: The Last Airbender* who tells every visitor there is no war in Ba Sing Se. The caption was “Philippines, Asean Summit 2026:” and the line under it said there is no traffic, poverty, corruption or bad governance in Ba Sing Se. It is a good joke. It is also right about the walls.
The Philippines has been painting over its poor for visitors for fifty years. In 1974, ahead of Miss Universe in Manila, Imelda Marcos had walls whitewashed along the airport routes to screen shanties from view. In 1976, for the IMF-World Bank meetings, the PICC itself was rushed to completion, fourteen luxury hotels went up on government-backed loans, and families were cleared out of Tondo. Accounts of that eviction differ by a factor of a thousand, from about 60 families in one telling to about 60,000 in another, and I could not settle that from the records I found. What nobody disputes is that Tondo stayed poor and the hotels became a byword for the “edifice complex.” Plywood walls hid squatters before APEC in 1996. Street children were reportedly rounded up before Pope Francis arrived in 2015, and the welfare department later admitted taking homeless families to a Batangas resort for a “camping activity” during the visit. This week, painted walls went up on Diokno Boulevard, vendors were cleared from Roxas Boulevard and Baclaran, and a group for street dwellers called the displacement reckless. The Palace calls it security. When ACT Teachers Rep. Antonio Tinio asked that vendors be compensated and guaranteed a way back, he asked for something specific and reasonable. The government should do it.
The façade complaint is correct, and it has been correct every time. What does not follow is the usual next step: that the summit is only a show, and that the country has no business hosting until it has fixed itself.
Ollero is a stand-up comic. His Netflix special was about fast food and the Filipino self-image we sell to tourists, not about foreign policy. I could find no record of him saying anything about ASEAN, APEC 2015 or the 2019 SEA Games, so I am not going to invent a worked-out position for him. The argument is not owned by the left. Bayan-aligned groups have used it for decades, but this week the same complaint ran in a Pang-Masa editorial, in several Daily Tribune columns and in a Manila Times column. It has become the commentariat’s default reaction to anything the government hosts, which is why it deserves a test instead of another recitation.
Really, I have to ask, when would the Philippines be allowed to host?
The argument never anything about this. Is it when the poverty rate falls below a number, when EDSA moves at a certain speed, when the last flood-control contractor is in jail?
It names no standard and no deadline, so no result could ever satisfy it, and Metro Manila has had traffic, poverty and corruption every year since this country co-founded ASEAN in 1967.
By that logic we should never have hosted anything. The argument also gets used by whoever is out of power.
In 2019, then-Senate Minority Leader Franklin Drilon mocked the ₱50-million SEA Games cauldron as a “kaldero” that could have built classrooms, and former President Noynoy Aquino agreed with him. Then-Speaker Alan Peter Cayetano answered that Aquino’s own ₱10-billion APEC 2015 budget could have built ten thousand classrooms.
Each side aimed it at the other’s event and never at its own. That is a weapon.
It also treats hosting and governing as if they compete for the same effort. They do not.
The departments are different, the budget lines are different, and a summit lasts a few days. The argument offers no alternative. We did not stumble into this chairship. In 2023, ASEAN agreed that the Philippines would take Myanmar’s turn in 2026, because Myanmar’s junta was in no position to lead, and Manila had been scheduled for 2027.
Declining would not have cleaned a single estero. The chair would simply have passed to someone else, along with the power to set the agenda on the South China Sea.
The better criticism is about money. The government has set aside ₱22.9 billion for the 2026 chairship, against about ₱1 billion under Arroyo in 2007 and ₱3.79 billion actually spent in 2017. A Manila Times columnist put the 2017 figure at roughly ₱5.5 billion in today’s money, so even adjusted, the gap is large.
The Palace answers that the figure covers the whole year: two summits including the May meeting in Cebu, more than 550 meetings against 279 in 2017, renovations at the PICC, airport works and about 20,000 police. It also says not all of it has been spent, and that it is ready for a Commission on Audit review.
Take it at its word and hold it there. A country still reeling from the flood-control scandal has every right to be suspicious. The right response is an itemized public accounting of security, venues, airport works and hospitality. Demand the audit. That is not a reason to skip the seat.
The credibility problem is harder. How does a government that arrested 276 people in Muntinlupa on the opening day, according to Rappler and the group Lakbayan ng Timog Katagalugan, lecture anyone about the rule of law? Bayan’s Renato Reyes Jr. called it the biggest single-day mass arrest under this administration, and the Palace told protesters not to tarnish the country’s reputation. That is a bad look and a bad instinct. A government confident in its democracy lets people march.
Credibility in ASEAN has never come from a spotless home record, because no member has one, and if it did the bloc would never meet. It comes from having a clear interest, a legal case and the stamina to keep pushing. On the South China Sea, Manila has all three, including the 2016 arbitral ruling. Whatever else the protests and arrests say about the government, they say little about whether it should be in the room.
The meme never gets to why the room matters. Compare 2017 with this year. At the 2017 summit under Duterte, the chairman’s statement did not mention China’s island-building, and the DFA explained that no leader had raised it. This year, the chair pushed a Code of Conduct negotiation through nine rounds and two senior officials’ meetings, and on November 15 Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said the parties had provisionally agreed on about 80 percent of the draft paragraphs.
It is not finished, and one of the open questions is the most important one: whether the code would be legally binding at all. That is a miss, and the government should say so plainly. You cannot write that paragraph from the audience. The chair’s seat is where the agenda gets set, and Singapore now inherits the unfinished job.
The pressure on Manila is also unusually visible this week. We are a treaty ally of the United States with large trading ties to China, and both are in town.
Chinese Premier Li Qiang co-chaired the ASEAN-China Summit with President Marcos on Monday, and the upgraded ASEAN-China free trade pact is reported to take effect on December 1. Donald Trump arrives Tuesday for a special ASEAN-US summit and, according to reports, leaves for APEC in Shenzhen soon after.
A middle power between two giants has few tools. One of the better ones is a bloc of eleven nations that can speak with one voice when it manages to. That only works if the members who care most about rules push hardest, and on the sea, that is us. ASEAN’s limits are real. It decides by consensus, it has not stopped the civil war in Myanmar, and it is better known for photo-ops than for outcomes. The fix for a consensus body is a member that works the room harder, not one that leaves it. Stepping back “to fix things at home first” would hand an advantage to whichever power prefers to deal with the Philippines alone.
Judge the next two days by outcomes, in this order.
1. The South China Sea code. Watch whether the chairman’s statement sets a deadline for Singapore, uses the words “legally binding” and “effective and substantive,” and refers to international law and UNCLOS. A vague promise to “continue negotiations” is a failure dressed up as progress.
2. The wording of the sea statement. See whether it names specific incidents, such as water-cannon attacks and dangerous maneuvers, or only expresses “concerns,” and compare it with the 2017 statement that said nothing about island-building.
3. What the United States delivers on Tuesday. Look for written commitments on maritime security and trade rather than a photo-op, and for anything that comes out of the Marcos-Trump bilateral. The US ambassador has said the Pax Silica semiconductor hub will not be signed this week, so a surprise signing would deserve questions.
4. What China delivers. The trade upgrade is real. Watch whether it comes with any easing of pressure at sea, or whether Beijing again separates trade gains from its conduct in the water.
5. Myanmar. See whether ASEAN moves beyond repeating calls for de-escalation, with any change in how the junta is treated or any concrete humanitarian access.
6. Timor-Leste’s first summit as a full member. Look for a real support package to help Dili meet its obligations, not just a welcome ceremony.
7. Economic deliverables you can count. Signed agreements and investment pledges with names and amounts count; any number without a signature behind it does not. The Philippines-Canada trade talks, reported as concluded with signing planned for 2027, are one to track.
8. The plus-one summits with Japan, Korea, India and Australia. Watch for maritime and defense cooperation that lets the Philippines spread its bets beyond Washington and Beijing.
9. Whether the Philippines visibly led. At the closing press conference, who speaks first on the sea, and what does Marcos say as he hands the chair to Singapore?
10. The bill. The Palace has promised an itemized accounting and a COA audit of the ₱22.9 billion. Note the date it is published. If it never arrives, the critics were right about more than the walls.
11. The people who were moved. Check whether the vendors on Roxas Boulevard, in Baclaran and along Diokno Boulevard get back to their spots and get compensated, and whether the arrested protesters get due process.
That last item is where Ollero’s meme and this article end up together. The test is whether the government can host without hiding the poor and answer for what it spends. If it can, the walls were a mistake and the summit was still worth having. If it cannot, the critics will have earned every joke.
Some of this is honestly unsettled. There is little hard evidence either way on what summits return in investment or tourism, and until the audit is out neither the Palace’s “money well spent” nor the critics’ “it never reaches ordinary Filipinos” can be proven. Reasonable people also disagree on where security ends and image-making begins, since 20 heads of state do require closed roads while murals in front of shanties do not. Skeptics who point to more than two decades without a Code of Conduct and five years of war in Myanmar have a case. ASEAN’s defenders, who say its value is keeping both great powers at the table and giving small states a voice, have one too. Even the Potemkin story behind the whole “façade” idea is probably a myth, since most historians say the fake villages of 1787 were a smear, which is a fair reminder that “it’s all a show” is itself a story that gets used for politics.
There is no war in Ba Sing Se. There is a standoff in the West Philippine Sea, and the one room where eleven countries sit down to talk about it is the one we are hosting this week. Show up, push harder, open the books, and leave the vendors where they are.
- Red Ollero: There Is No Summit in Ba Sing Se - November 16, 2026
- “Adik” – Not So Meaningless - October 7, 2026
- Washes 50% Whiter? Why Moral Slogans Make Bad Governance - September 30, 2026