Hindi Pwede Kami Magtagal Dito.My Impressions of Sean Ellis’ Metro Manila



And them South Side sisters sure look pretty

The cripple on the corner cries out, “Nickels for your pity.”

And them downtown boys sure talk gritty

It’s so hard to be a saint in the city


Bruce Springsteen 

Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us.
Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider!
Learn more

Metro Manila


“Hindi pwede kami magtagal dito. “- that is the Tagalog phrase as I remember it from the movie that Mai Ramirez says at least twice in the Sean Ellis film “Metro Manila”. The first time she comes to that conclusion after seeing an abduction of a woman in plain view of her family and everybody else in a busy street.  In terms of disturbing imagery the movie was only getting started. There is no way you can begin to make an honest portrayal of “Metro Manila ” in a general patronage movie.


I write a lot and I love movies but I am not too keen on the idea of movie reviews. Maybe I quit reading reviews because of the bad taste in my mouth I got years ago reading Nestor Torre in the Inquirer when he felt it was his duty to tell you the ending of movies. I will give you some thoughts and if you insist on calling it a review well that’s on you. I already feel bad about having to reveal some plot lines but I will not spoil anything.  If you want some background on the production you may go here. I rather know as little as possible about any movie and let the movie itself speak to me.

An 80% price drop in a commodity. That is all it took for rice farmer Oscar Ramirez to uproot his family of four from Benguet to Metro Manila. When the family gets to their destination the patriarch utters a phrase like they are in heaven. Sadly the city is not as welcoming as we would like for a family man who seems to have his heart in the right place. A fellow job seeker on the first day helps out with accommodations by playing middleman to a “landlord”. Later on the family rudely finds out that the real landlord is the local government who begin to usher in the real tenants. Oscar shows resourcefulness and the ability to create a win-win scenario between him and a man in a pickup looking for casual, manual labor. As we find out later, just like the accommodations, all that glitters is not gold as the Led Zeppelin song goes.


That should be the first lesson anyone should learn no matter what age. If something is too good to be true it isn’t. All these get rich quick schemes, which are so easy yet you don’t know one person who made a living out of it. Remember that the next time you see a FB post saying, “This is not a scam”. Earn $1000 a day in doing social networking at home. Brings to mind the slogan of GRP writer Ilda ” Things are not always what they seem”.


Oscar and Mai eventually settle in “jobs”. Mai in place where the female interviewer criticizes her in the first minute for showing physical signs of lactating. Oscar it seems lucks into his work at an armored car transport service because he was spotted in the queue sporting a military tattoo. Both jobs have their own measure of risk Oscar is tasked to drive a bulky armored car with limited sight lines in chaotic Manila traffic and part of the orientation mentions him getting a counterfeit drivers license downtown. Nice nod to the culture there. There seems to be no regulation to brandish and fire a high powered fire arm but go ahead get a fake driver’s license.


I like how the film captured the true subtle Metro Manila spirit with a scene similar to this one.

I like how the film captured the true subtle Metro Manila spirit with a scene similar to this one.


As in anything the little touches add to the experience. Scene of the jaywalker dodging moving cars is so indicative of the self-entitlement I see every day traversing the streets. In fact it answers an old riddle. The older of the two daughters really looks like her screen mother. She asked Oscar very early in the movie where would he go when he dies. The answer was very reminiscent of E.T.  I have never had to work in an establishment that Mai ends up working at but making allowance for the kids to be present in the work place does remind me of a scene from Paul Verhoven’s “Showgirls”.


It is explained to Oscar that he is signing up for an extremely dangerous job. This is a good time to extol the virtues of John Arcilla who plays Ong who served as mentor, friend, and benefactor for Oscar. Of course like anything else in Metro Manila there are strings attached. I did enjoy the Ong character that serves as both a buffer as well as a conduit between Oscar and Metro Manila. Whether it is too close for comfort (spoiler alert: you may highlight the gap to read) to Denzel Washington’s character in Training Day is for you to decide.


As husband and wife get more intertwined in their respective jobs the film reached a point where the juxtaposition of their situations results in a gotcha moment. Just like in Hangover 2 where the notion was “Bangkok has him now”. Well Metro Manila had both of them. There is no need for Dorothy to come out and tell them they are no longer in Kansas. As Springsteen sang “It’s hard to be a saint in the city”.

Metro Manila Film Review Movie Jake Althea


I am in no position to critique acting but here goes. Jake Macapagal does project a very believable aw shucks  attitude. I bought the simpleton act but upon reflection the character of Oscar was suitable for his inevitable job because he did time in the military. So my question, is this a reasonable state for his character to be in considering any kind of military experience would (I presume) have washed that naivety right out of him?


It is mentioned in GRP and elsewhere that we live in a culture of impunity. The parallel tale that Oscar tells throughout the movie is a good example of that. It is a story of his past and actually reminds me of something I wrote on how human life in the Philippines is anything but sacred. The tale did remind me a bit of one of the stories in Pulp Fiction. The movie is entirely subtitled in English (at least our version). Which at times was a good thing because the outdoor dialogue at times sounded too diluted for me and I could not make out some words once in a while. I have no idea how this will play to audiences that don’t live here or are not immersed in the culture although  there is  this review in the Guardian.


IMG_0037 2b 1


Inevitably we reach a crossroads point in the story where Oscar can emulate Ong more than he already has, fail bitterly in providing for his family or take some other new path. That I will not give away. I believe Ellis wrapped up the story well. Watch the movie. Mai may not have wanted to linger in Metro Manila but “Metro Manila” did indeed linger with me.


Sean Ellis’ “Metro Manila” will be in theaters Oct 9 2013.


24 Replies to “Hindi Pwede Kami Magtagal Dito.My Impressions of Sean Ellis’ Metro Manila”

      1. Sundance Festival & Cannes Film Festival = god tier
        mmff = shit tier

        Cry some more dummkopf. Your tears are once again very delicious.

      1. Kung ang ‘sariling atin’ ay ubod ng PANGIT then what’s the point about it?

        Yep, this is foreign. But the film itself isn’t sugarcoating Metro Manila and the perspective of living there. It was all REAL.

        Saka ko na lang tangkilikin ang ‘sariling atin’ if Filipino filmmakers will go on QUALITY than QUANTITY. You always go on your ‘Juan dela Cruz’ and ‘Bossing’ nonsense yet you never mention Brillante Mendoza.

        TROLL. 😀

      2. Yeah right sariling atin you dummkopf. Like ripping off most of the Hollywood movies like last years enteng kabisote which rips-off The Avengers. And there you go with your anti-foreign hypocrisy again. Wag ka na lang gumamit ng gawang dayuhan na PC mo para pang-troll mo sa amin. Bumili ka na lang ng produktong 100% pinoy. C’mon I dare you ultranationalist.

    1. Asa ka pa dummkopf. “Metro Manila” will not be in mmff not because it’s a foreign movie. It’s because mmff already lost its charm ever since they nominate nothing but garbage movies.

  1. BK/ Vicente / Sendong . If Ricky fires you for not making quota , we can use you here with us. We need a replacement toilet. Since you seem to know crap so well.

  2. Nah star cinema and other mainstream local film distributors shows nothing but immoral dramas and abysmal comedies because they always use the pwede na iyan mentality. And serves you right for your comments to be deleted. Wala ka nang matira sa amin kundi puro palpak na lang e. Now pwede bang bigyan mo kami ng pera mo na binayad sa iyo ni carandung? Mukhang malaki naman e.
    Oh and Lino Brocka and Ishmael Bernal are far more greater Filipino filmmakers than your amateur shitheads.

  3. Looks like BK has become a ghost since we can’t see his stupid propaganda anymore. Good riddance to bad rubbish.

  4. Public choices these days regulate the entertainment marketplace in a way that has beeninconceivable before the web together with the viral circulation of news, in addition tocomplete entertainment content. If you add to that distribution online and, media, websites online, from rumor to whole movies. This is a totally new environment. Some of it very good, some not.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.