Three really appalling ideas being spread by prominent Filipino opinion shapers

Consider the reality of democratic politics. Just about anyone can be President. Guys like former President Joseph “Erap” Estrada and current President Benigno “Noynoy” Aquino III are a testament to this truth. For that matter, any position in government that only requires that its occupant be elected by popular vote is subject to the tyranny of the majority ignorant. And the Philippines, to the tune of a hundred million and rapidly growing shows no signs that the quality of the Majority Vote will be changing anytime soon. What with basic public education and health services unable to keep up with galloping population growth, the essential ingredients to building intelligence into the “voice” of the people — world-class education, proper nutrition, and lead-free air — are woefully in short supply.

As such, it is not surprising that the prevailing wisdom — the national perspective — is easily monopolised and perverted by a powerful clique of political engineers — because popularity rules. The Court of Public Opinion still remains the de facto beacon for the public perception of what is supposedly “right”. This is no less than a national tragedy considering how this perception is shaped largely by the country’s mainstream media and entertainment industries — both of which can hardly be cited as beacons of intellectual pursuit. I cited in my book the observations made by eminent columnist Isagani Cruz in an Inquirer column back in 2006…

Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us.
Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider!
Learn more

The Philippine entertainment industry is not only a vast wasteland, as television has been described in America, but a vicious instrument for the abatement of the nation’s intelligence. The shows it offers for the supposed recreation of the people are generally vulgar and smutty, usually with some little moral lesson inserted to make them look respectable, but offensive nonetheless. On the whole, they are obnoxious and unwholesome and deserve to be trashed.

The indiscriminate audience eagerly laps them up because it has not been taught to be selective and more demanding of better quality shows for their pastime. In fact, the easily satisfied fans have been taught the exact opposite reaction — to accept whatever garbage the industry offers them and, to add insult to their injury, to pay for it too.

The leaders of the entertainment industry are supposed to be responsible people but they have evaded their duty to elevate the taste of their mostly unthinking supporters. They have instead cheapened them into a mass of automated individuals whose ultimate joy is to roll up in the aisles at the lewd jokes of potential senators.

Back then it was mainly the entertainment subset of Philippine Media that was engaged in wholesale degradation of what meagre intelligence Filipinos collectively possess. What is disturbing is how this effort to subtract from what is left of the smarts of Philippine society is now being mounted by some of the more trusted “intellectuals” of the country. Indeed, people we once thought to have a better-than-average head on their shoulders (by Philippine standards) have for one reason or another (perhaps depending on what personal stake they might happen to have on the status quo) come down upon Philippine society unleashing a plague of misguided ideas and notions.

The following is a sample of some of the most appalling ideas I have come across within the small cross-section of the media and popular culture I observe the most closely.

* * *

(1) Rule of Law is a detestable notion.

This one was made famous by ABS-CBN contributing reporter Raissa Robles who on one hand wrote how she “grimaces” whenever she comes across the term while, on the other, herself admits that she is “just” an English major and probably knows no better than the “far wiser” justices of the Philippine Supreme Court.

Robles’s basis for slapping her verdict upon the venerable edifice of Rule of Law upon which the great civilisations of this planet were built was a “well researched” account of the performance of the Philippine Supreme Court during the regime of former President Ferdinand Marcos. She then uses this account to show that the SC of today cannot be relied upon to act in a manner that is aligned with “the interests of the Filipino people” and, as such, their being the institutional embodiment of the Rule of Law necessarily makes that notion de facto detestable.

Classy. Ms Raissa Robles should leave the thinking to those of us who know how to do it properly.

Perhaps the above cognitive gaffe of a reporter can be excused. But what is really scarily disappointing is how a stalwart thought leader of Philippine society can get it so wrong…

(2) Popular support for a person or idea necessarily makes said person or idea right.

This is according to the venerable Professor Randy David who recently got inducted into the Demagoguery Hall of Infamy that counts as its members many high-profile bozos who’ve made a career of highlighting how political power is lent “legitimacy” by the nebulous notion of “the people’s will”. Referring to the recent presidential tirade against the Supreme Court even as its Chief sat a couple of metres away, David noted, “It is an encouraging sign that the public seems to side with President Aquino, whose shaking voice betrayed not only anger but a certain discomfort at having to tell people to their faces that they ought to be ashamed of themselves.”

The key assumption at work here is that Noynoy still embodies the “spirit” of the Laban (“Fight”) movement that is a relic of 1980’s politics. Unfortunately, the notion of some sort of “fight” going on in Philippine politics becomes absurd considering that much of the institutional governance measures that were lacking back then are pretty much now in place.

Despite the basic institutions and processes now being in place (flawed as they may be), the imperative to build upon these seems to have not captured the spirit of the society. We are pretty much still looking for a fight where there is none.

Indeed, as the eminent constitutionalist Fr Joaquin Bernas SJ reminds us

Government officials have only so much authority as is given to them by law and the Constitution, and not what they might assume to be given to them by popular rallies.

“Professor” Randy David should update his thinking to 21st Century standards.

(3) Former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo is “evil” and had presided over one of the darkest chapters in Philippine history.

This is a popular sentiment that’s been cultivated and propagated over many years. In her seminal article Ten reasons why Filipinos blame Gloria Arroyo for everything, my colleague Ilda articulated the specifics around how the underbelly of the Filipino psyche — that world-renowned Filipino Condition — served as fertile ground for this virulent memetic beast to successfully infest the Filipino mind.

But it was President Noynoy Aquino himself who crystallised the notion of the Arroyo administration as the Evil Regime. After failing to get the presumptuously-named “Truth Commission” up and running at the start of his term as President, an exasperated Noynoy sighed, “We established the ‘Truth Commission’ to close one of the darkest eras of the history of our society,” effectively putting the Arroyo era in the same league as the 20-year dictatorship of former President Marcos and the Japanese occupation of World War II.

* * *

Perhaps it is high time Filipinos get a grip, step back and regard the din of clever mind tricks being played on them by the very politicians they detest and the media personalities that they idolise, and think. Is the Rule of Law really negotiable? Does the popularity of an idea necessarily confirm its validity? Was Arroyo’s regime really that bad?

Consider these questions and start to understand what Noynoy and his extended network of family and cronies are really after. Perhaps when we look back and see how little Noynoy actually did first as Congressman, then as Senator, we begin to wonder: Why froth in the mouth about evil, injustice, and corruption now? And then everything falls into place. The family jewels are at stake. If I were Noynoy, I’d be shittin’ bricks too.

26 Replies to “Three really appalling ideas being spread by prominent Filipino opinion shapers”

  1. Hindi naipasa ang Truth Commission dahil nandyan ang midnight appointee na si Corona na pabor palagi kay Gloria. At totoo naman sira talaga ang bansa pagkatapos ng termino ni Gloria, tignan mo utang ng NFA lumobo. Magnanakaw yan e pati tatay niya.

    1. Hindi pumasa ang Truth Comission dahil sa “rule of law.”

      Sino nagpaaral sa iyo? Si GMA ba ang may kasalanan ng lahat? Huwag mo isama ang ama niya sa katarantaduhan mo!

      Yung boss mo gumawa ng aktong kriminal. Nanigarilyo siya sa PAL B-747 flight na galing San Francisco.

      Bakit bagsak ang ekonomiya ngayon?

      Ipaliwanag mo nga kung bakit sa pagpupulong ng LEDAC sa malascanang ang gastos sa dalawang pakain ay 860,000 pesos? Di ba korupsyon ito ng amo mong sira?

      Sabi niya ang Diyos daw kakampi niya! Magpakunwari ang amo mo. Hindi siya maka-Diyos! Kasama niya ang kampon ng kadiliman! Linlangin mo ang mga gago at gaga gaya mo!

    2. Kung meron mang Truth Commission o wala dapat yang tatanga tangang Abnoy at de Lima na yan nag ipon ng bala na ebidensya para mag FILE NG KASO. Kaso nga tatanga tanga sila. Akala nila ang korte COURT OF PUBLIC OPINION sa corrupt tri-media op da Piripins.

    3. B0B0 ka talaga
      Nasira ang bansa dahil kay Pnoy kasi incompetent siya katulad mo.
      Kung sinasabi mo na gumaganda ang economy natin kay pnoy eh bakit tumataas ng tumataas ang presyo ng mga bilihin at gasolina??

  2. beautifully written piece.
    clear and concise and accurate.
    i only wish there was some independent debate on mainstream tv.

    hacienda luisita.
    looking at the published figures and with some simple maths it would seem that the sc ruling will cost the cojuangcos est. 5 – 7 Billion pesos in the short term with a long term opportunity cost of est. 20 – 30 billion pesos ( land development) which would skyrocket if part 2 of the plan – the govt develop clark as international hub with rail links and ? rail link to tarlac all paid for by taxpayer. tarlac the new capital of the philippines!
    cojuangcos new airline based at clark and his part ownership of clark through 3rd party company means all ducks in a row except for sc ruling, so urgent to stop hli audit(too many secrets could be uncovered) and overturn ruling.
    this is pnoys only task and he needs to act fast hence the first time he has ever broken into a sweat about anything.
    are people so blind and the media so corrupt/in pocket that they dont at least ask questions

      1. agreed
        its in motion
        more mainstream media propaganda
        malacanan already control/influence
        editorial, programmes and opinion surveys.
        soon subliminal advertising!

      2. In my view, ABS-CBN seems to be Aquino’s main station than NBN… So, ABS-CBN is the de facto station of the government(NBN remains “some sort of de jure”, however).

    1. Even Congressmen were herded like cattle into the slaughterhouse in this recent impeachment circus. So I doubt that most ordinary schmoes could get up the balls — or the brains — to mount a proper debate about issues like these.

  3. All our local networks follow the same non-sense and stupid format. They all sound and look the same. Even their commercial breaks for prime time shows are aired at exactly the same time. I sometimes watch shows of other Asian countries on cable and guess what? Although with english subtitles, they are polite and civil. I still have to see a soap opera of theirs that has shouting matches, rants, prolonged crying and agony, being dirt poor, ugly, uneducated and in love with a very rich guy, grabbing other peoples spouses, a storyline so common among our own networks. If our shows are laden with tons of annoying commercials, theirs are few and far between.I do not wish to compare but the difference is very glaring. Why they dominate over sober and more amusing channels is really a “puzzlement”.
    Speaking of Father Bernas, involving him as one of the framers of the 1987 constitution was a big mistake. My reason is because he is an officer of the worlds largest organized religion – the catholic church. It is not unlikely that he influenced incorporating his religious beliefs in crafting our constitution. Other religious organizations should also be not allowed to impose their beliefs into the law of the land.

  4. Hope people realize that opposing the Supreme Court is the cause of instability in the country, and not the Supreme Court itself.

  5. Gee whiz Benigz! These are not really new, are they? I mean, Rule of Law being detestable and Popular Approval being desirable fit the twisted logic of the Land of Palusots and Papansins. Them propaganda hackers are just utilizing the basic bugs in the cultural matrix to attain their desired results.

    Dark era of history, you say. Well, it couldn’t be WW2, with all the bombs and tracer bullets illuminating the skies. Nor with the Marcos dictatorship (it’s just dark for the Lopezes because they lost Meralco). That period of eight hour blackouts, with a healthy sprinkling of volcanic ash–now that’s some real darkness. There can only be one Queen of Darkness!

    1. Indeed, they are nothing new, just like Pinoy stupidity precedes the GMA administration – a reality that is self-evident despite all attempts by these bozos to make it look like all of the problems of da Pinas originated from the former president’s “evil” ways.

  6. We are gullible Wowoowee people; easily manupulated by Dramas and Telenovelas. This is the reason Noynoy Aquino is diverting the attention of the people: he cannot solve the problems of the economy. Prices of basic commodities are going up and up. While he indulges in politics. His interest in his Hacienda Luisita is more important than your interest. He wants to monopolize power…this is very dangerous…

  7. Gawds, finally read something sensible… the current debacle between the SC and the president has been a source of frustration these past few days.

    People are hailing the president for his acts but little do they know that his actions are already marks of a tyrannical rule. in our country where the rule of law is given little regard, and where media influences everything, it is easy to be swayed by popular opinion, whether they be right or wrong. I’m glad that there are sites like these that are not afraid to speak the truth, unpopular they may be. it is difficult since we are a minority but with collective effort, we may be able to remove the blindfold that binds most of our countrymen.

    suntok sa buwan ika nga, but it’s better than doing nothing. during these times when the very essence of democracy is threatened, hindi puwedeng tumanga na lang tayo.

    and to mr alconce: fr bernas was asked to help draft the constitution not by virtue of his status as a priest but because of his expertise in constitutional and political law. he was one of those independent-minded people who helped promote awareness and critical-thinking during the dark times of the martial law.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.