I was hurrying back to Manila from a meeting in Makati when it hit me, with a groan, that my Grab driver had taken a “shortcut” through Santa Ana. It had been raining for half an hour. If you’ve ever been through that part of the city in the rain, you know what that means. I slunk deep into my seat, resigned to an hour of crawling, as the car began wading through one of the district’s chronically flooded roads.
I would have dozed off. Then came the slosh of dark, stinking water under the floor, and leptospirosis suddenly became real. Every gurgle and wet slap beneath my seat set the old news hound in me whimpering. I’d read the report: forty people dead from the disease. Number forty-one was not a title I wanted. So much for my glacial detachment. It boiled off into a heavy fog of panic.
Santa Ana sits in a crook of the Pasig River’s serpentine path, packed tight with houses and buildings, in Manila’s 6th District. Long before the Spaniards came, it was the seat of the kingdom of Namayan. The Spaniards renamed the town Santa Ana de Sapa. Santa Ana “of the stream.” For centuries the land has been telling its people the same thing. You live with water. The water always comes back.
| SUPPORT INDEPENDENT SOCIAL COMMENTARY! Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider! Learn more |

I caught myself asking how the people who control billions of pesos in public money could let this keep happening. They know. Anyone can see that without proper flood control, Santa Ana gets the same floods and the same diseases, year after year. Nobody should need a billboard to warn them of a danger the river has been announcing for centuries.
But the flood wasn’t the only thing on my mind as we crawled through it. Through the window, I watched people drenched in rainwater and sweat, fighting to keep the water out of their homes with sandbags and buckets. They made me think of my friends who live a few streets away, and of the hurt in their voices when they told me their stories. Every one of them was about hope being swept away.
They told me about the long wait on May 13, 2025, outside the canvassing center, and I can picture it. The warm air clung to their skin like wax. They paced enough to run a marathon. Then came the final tally, read from a sheet of paper bearing every mark of authority. The words were noise until they caught, “Joey Uy… 64,746 votes…” Cheers and shouts drowned out the rest: “Benny Abante… 63,358…” A margin of 1,388. Not a landslide. Solid ground.
My friends celebrated the way ordinary people do on the rare days life lets them win. When the news showed up on their feeds, it confirmed they hadn’t slipped on a mossy sidewalk, hit their heads, and dreamed the whole thing. COMELEC proclaimed Uy the winner. On May 26, he took his oath as the district’s congressman before Manila Regional Trial Court Executive Judge Carolina Icasiano-Sison. The certificate was signed. The oath was sworn.
The ground felt dry.
It wasn’t. Four days before the oath, on May 22, Abante had filed a petition with COMELEC claiming Uy was not a natural-born Filipino. Uy got five days to answer. On June 18, COMELEC’s Second Division ruled against him, reasoning that his mother had lost her citizenship when she married a Chinese national. On June 30, the very day the Constitution says a new congressman’s term begins, the COMELEC en banc annulled his proclamation and declared the candidate with fewer votes the winner. Uy ran to the Supreme Court that same day.
Six weeks. Certified, sworn, washed out. Like every flood in Santa Ana, it came in stages, and by the time anyone noticed, it was over everyone’s ankles.
My friends don’t feel like they lost an election. They feel robbed.
They had lined up under the sun, voted for a man they’d known for years as their councilor, and watched him take his oath. Then a commission none of them elected told them their votes came down to a paperwork problem. Nobody knocked on their doors. Nobody explained. Their choice was struck out like a typo. The curses came fast, in the kind of Tagalog this site won’t print, and every one of them was aimed at COMELEC.
Then came the stories. You’ve heard them too, if you’ve spent any time around Manila politics: seats said to be for sale, rulings said to bend toward whoever has the right friends, envelopes changing hands where no camera can see. My friends told them the way people tell ghost stories, half-believing and fully angry. I can’t verify any of it, and I’m not saying it happened here. But when an institution makes its biggest decisions behind closed doors, after the votes are counted, the people it overrules will assume the worst. Secrecy breeds that kind of distrust, and my friends’ anger is the bill COMELEC still hasn’t paid.
I understood that anger because I’ve watched this from the inside. In 2016, I was on Grace Poe’s presidential campaign when COMELEC disqualified her over citizenship and residency. The Supreme Court reversed it, and her name stayed on the ballot. Different case, same question. How much power should an appointed commission have to override what voters decide?
So let’s look at what COMELEC actually ruled, and bear with me, because this is where it gets interesting. Uy was born in 1962 to a Chinese father and a mother who was born Filipina. Under the 1935 Constitution, in force at the time, a child like him could claim natural-born status through his mother. COMELEC shut that door by ruling that his mother was no longer Filipino when he was born. Her marriage, it said, had cost her the citizenship.
On the law, COMELEC’s theory has substance. Under Commonwealth Act No. 63, a Filipina who married a foreigner lost her citizenship if her husband’s country’s law gave her his nationality, and Chinese law of that era generally did. But in Philippine courts, foreign law is a fact. It must be proven like any other fact, and the burden falls on the one who alleges it. The House Electoral Tribunal has applied that rule to cases much like this one, refusing to presume that a Filipina became Chinese simply by marrying a Chinese man. Uy’s petition points out that Abante never cited the specific law and never proved that Uy’s mother acquired Chinese citizenship.
Consider, then, the evidence on which a district’s vote was overturned.
It was a set of photocopied immigration certificates from 1967, issued when Uy was five years old, and handed in by a “concerned citizen” nobody would name.
Our Rules on Evidence are not obscure on this point. A government record must be proven by the original or by a copy certified by the office that keeps it. In *Matugas v. COMELEC* (2004), the Supreme Court refused to accept an uncertified photocopy as proof of a public record.
According to Uy’s petition, these papers carried no certification.
No custodian vouched for them.
No named person stood behind them.
Uy asked for a hearing to challenge them. COMELEC ruled without one.
A man was stripped of a seat sixty-four thousand people gave him, on paper a first-year law student would object to, and he was never allowed to ask where it came from.
And even if COMELEC were right about his mother, Uy has a fallback. The Supreme Court has seen almost exactly this case before. In *Co v. HRET* (1991), Jose Ong Jr. had a Filipina mother and a father naturalized when Ong was a boy. The Court held that voting and taking part in elections count as electing citizenship, and that demanding a formal election from someone the law had already made a citizen would be absurd. Uy’s father was naturalized when Uy was five. Like Ong, who had won a seat in Congress, Uy spent his life acting as a citizen: born and raised in Manila, schooled here, a regular voter, a councilor for several terms. His petition adds a jurisdictional argument too. Once he had taken his oath and assumed office, only the House Electoral Tribunal could rule on his qualifications. More than a year later, the Supreme Court has yet to decide, and Abante holds the seat. If I were betting, I’d bet on Uy.
Here’s the part that should bother you no matter whose side you’re on. The rule that would have prevented all of this already exists. Section 78 of the Omnibus Election Code says a petition to cancel a candidate’s certificate of candidacy must be filed within 25 days of its filing, and decided no later than 15 days before the election. Settle eligibility before people vote. That’s the whole point. Uy filed his certificate on October 1, 2024, so the window to challenge it closed on October 26. Nobody did.
Twenty-five days. Abante filed seven months later, after the election and after the proclamation. According to Uy’s petition, COMELEC took it up anyway by docketing it as a “Special Case,” a category meant for disputes that arise before proclamation.
The referee ignored its own rulebook. Sixty-four thousand voters in a district that floods every rainy season paid for it.
COMELEC’s other great power gets even less scrutiny. The commission runs the Automated Election System largely on its own. Every cycle brings reports of failed machines, corrupted SD cards, and transmission problems; in 2019, results stalled for about seven hours. Each incident gets explained, then forgotten until the next election. Congress has little appetite to dig, since few lawmakers want a fight with the agency that will referee their next race.
None of this needs new heroics. First, enforce the law already on the books: late petitions under Section 78 should be dismissed outright, and Congress can make that dismissal mandatory so no commission can talk its way around it. Second, any proceeding that can undo a proclamation should require a full hearing and properly authenticated evidence. Third, the Automated Election System should face an independent, regular audit with published findings. And fourth, COMELEC’s own powers deserve a periodic structural review, done by people who don’t need its goodwill.
By the time my Grab car made it out of Santa Ana, the water was already draining, leaving a skin of mud on the pavement and on the doorsteps of houses that hadn’t kept it out. That’s what floods do. They recede, and everyone pretends it won’t happen again.
My friends in the 6th District know better. Whatever the Supreme Court decides about Joey Uy, it shouldn’t take a petition for certiorari to keep a district’s vote from going under.
—
*Editor’s note (October 2026): This article has been revised. It now draws on Joey Uy’s petition before the Supreme Court (G.R. No. 280887), corrects details of the case timeline, presents both sides of the citizenship question more fully, and removes anecdotes that could not be independently verified.*
*Tony Ramos writes independently on Philippine politics, economics, and society. He has no newsroom behind him, no press ID, and no budget, which means officials and campaigns don’t always answer his questions. He does his best with public records, court filings, and people willing to talk.*
*If you’re named in this piece and want your side told, write to him at [email]. He will publish your response. If you have documents or information that would make this story more complete, he wants to hear from you too.*
*And if you think this kind of writing is worth more of, share it. Reach is the only press ID an independent writer gets.*
- Red Ollero: There Is No Summit in Ba Sing Se - November 16, 2026
- “Adik” – Not So Meaningless - October 7, 2026
- Washes 50% Whiter? Why Moral Slogans Make Bad Governance - September 30, 2026
Granting that Joey Uy had citizenship violations and COMELEC is right to disqualify him, there’s no legal basis to proclaim Benny Abante as the winner because he’s not elected. The Supreme Court said that there is no law which recognizes the second placer rule in case the winning candidate gets disqualified before he gets sworn in and take office.