Could hiring practice biased towards women and minorities doom Silicon Valley?

According to a Huffington Post report there is “a diversity problem vexing the entire technology industry” because there are not enough women, black, and Hispanic people employed by Silicon Valley technology companies. Search giant Google, for its part, is seemingly under pressure to hire more people from those groups. It has mounted “a concerted effort to bring the numbers up” so much so that it claims that “21 percent of the workers that it hired for technology jobs last year were women.”


Yet, at the end of 2014, Google disclosed that only 2 percent of its US workforce were black and only 3 percent Hispanic.

Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us.
Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider!
Learn more

And so…

Mortified by the disclosures, Google and most of its other technology peers have been pouring more money into programs steering more women, blacks and Hispanics to focus on science and math in schools and have stepped up their recruiting of minority students as they prepare to graduate from college.

Civil rights leader Jesse Jackson, who has been spearheading the drive to diversify the tech industry, applauded Google for releasing its workforce data again to help keep the pressure on the technology industry to change the composition of its payroll.

“Tech companies must move from the aspiration of ‘doing better’ to concrete actionable hiring to move the needle,” Jackson said in a statement. “We aim to change the flow of the river.”

But the question is, the next time you spot an American Google employee who is a woman or a black or Hispanic person, what would you make of that sight? Will they be seen as evidence of a meritocratic system working on a level playing field? Or are they going to be regarded as a product of The Program to “move the needle”, in the Reverend Jesse Jackson’s words.

That depends on the philosophy behind the neo-affirmative action initiatives the US tech industry is currently coming to grips with.

Ultimately, business want to hire the most qualified people. As the late Michael Jackson (himself, an African-American man) once sang, “it don’t matter if you’re black or white” and it really is more about whether “you’re wrong or you’re right” regardless of colour. In short, it don’t matter what you are, male, female, black, Asian, white, or Hispanic, whatever. It’s all about whether you are wrong or you are right for the job.

Is there really a problem with the “diversity” statistics in the employee rolls of Silicon Valley companies like Google and Apple? That depends on your definition of “the problem”.

[Image courtesy Center for American Progress.]

6 Replies to “Could hiring practice biased towards women and minorities doom Silicon Valley?”

  1. I have worked with corporations in the Silicon Valley in California, U.S.A. I have seen a lot of Asian employees; especially in the Research and Development. Chinese, Koreans, Indians (Bombays), Vietnamese, a sprinking of Filipinos, etc…there are some women , also, but not many.

    Corporations hire the Best and the Brightest (top 10% of the graduating class) in well known universities…

    For those African American. Your inspiration should be, Dr. Benjamin Carsom, M.D. He grew up in Detoit, Michigan, U.S.A. Their father abandoned the family, when they were Children. They were raised by an illierate mother; who was a cleaning woman.

    Dr. Carson persevered to have an education. He graduated in University of Michigan; then, went to John Hopkins University Hospital, to specialize in brain surgery. He is now a contender for the Republican Party, for U.S. Presidency. Dr. Carson, realy inspires me.

    Companies hire to get ahead, and to rpoduce profits. Not to fulfill, minority hiring qoutas.

  2. Yeah limited push-paper jobs on STEM fields and they’re pushing away people with actual skills because of quotas, which is good because I hate google and apple lol.

  3. Last year I attended a seminar where a guest female speaker spoke about her experiences earning her degree while being a Latina in a predominantly white university. She began advocating that universities should hire more staff members of Latino background in order for the Hispanic students to have people to relate to. And I’m sitting there thinking ‘I can’t believe I’m hearing this.’

    This ‘need for diversity’ isn’t just limited to the tech industry, it’s everywhere. Many are still under the impression that companies hire based on a candidate’s qualifications. But in today’s increasingly liberal America that is slowly becoming less and less the case. You can see this push for multiculturalism and minority empowerment in so many facets of society now, it’s even saturated throughout the media. Everyone needs to represented regardless in some way that it has become a nationwide neurotic obsession. Just recently, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg donated 5 million dollars in student scholarships to undocumented immigrants. Ridiculous.

    Diversity should NOT be a policy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.