Alternative Media (Part 5): Subtle But Strong Messages

Okay, here’s Part 5 of Grimwald’s Alternative Media where yours truly will recommend things that you can read, watch or play instead of destroying your brain cells with local bovine manure.

So, without further ado…

Schindler’s List

Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us.
Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider!
Learn more

Ah, here’s a good one. A nice, if somewhat depressing film, directed by Steven Spielberg himself and stars Liam Neeson of Taken fame, Ralph Fiennes whom Harry Potter fans can immediately identify as the noseless villain Voldemort and Ben Kingsley, who is quite famous for portraying Mahatma Gandhi and the fake Mandarin of Iron Man 3. It’s quite an old film now but remains a classic to some because of its portrayal of the horrors that Jewish people had to endure during World War II. The film is shot almost completely in black and white to present both a “vintage” look and to underline the dark tone of the setting.

awartec037p1The film is based on the book Schindler’s Ark by Thomas Keneally and is an adaptation of the life of businessman Oskar Schindler during World War II. While some events have been embellished, one can say that the film is fairly accurate in its portrayal of those times when Nazi ideology held sway over Germany and its conquered territories.

Anyway, Oskar Schindler is portrayed, at least initially, as a greedy businessman seeking to take advantage of his Jewish workers who were already being discriminated against by the Nazis. Schindler, who was portrayed by Liam Neeson, was presented as a “gray” hero instead of an all-white one as he was not just greedy but also a womanizer and a member of the Nazi party (although he joined the Nazis more because of the advantages and benefits it offered rather than an adherence to its ideology). Over time though, as he sees the horror of what the “Final Solution” is actually about, he makes a change of heart, albeit slowly, and decides to help the Jewish workers under him and somehow protect them from the terrible atrocities taking place during the Holocaust. One of the turning points of the film is a little girl wearing a red coat, one of the few things in the movie that wasn’t black and white, which Schindler spots hiding among the crowd when the Nazis come to round up the Jews and sees again later as a corpse being burned along with many other victims of the Holocaust.

Ralph Fiennes plays the role of Amon Goeth who is quite possibly one of the worst villains I’ve ever encountered. To make matters worse, it has been mentioned that Steven Spielberg had to tone down the character’s evil because the real Amon Goeth was far worse in real life. That meant that sniping people for fun, summarily executing people and beating hapless women were the believable actions he committed, one can only wonder what else he did. Anyway, I will cite Amon Goeth as one of the best examples of a Jingoist as mentioned in one of my previous articles. While he was without a doubt a Nazi, he merely used his ideology as an excuse to satisfy his murderous impulses. I often stress to people that while Hitler’s regime was not without its merits, the presence of people like Amon Goeth and Josef Mengele in the Nazi party and Hitler’s willingness to tolerate them and their heinous acts is what really ruined Hitler’s reputation and shamed his country.

From a more personal point of view, I must say that the film is like a look at human nature and what true heroism is actually like. Both good and evil are choices I think and people do not have them by default. While Schindler was essentially a flawed man, he stepped up when people needed someone to save them. He made great sacrifices and risked his life to protect people he barely even knew because it was the right thing to do. On the other hand, you have Amon Goeth who also had a chance to do what was right. Schindler told him that showing mercy was a sign of greater power than cruelty and yet, still, Goeth chooses evil and kills a boy for petty reasons.

Valkyria Chronicles

I’m a big fan of both strategy and tactical games and Valkyria Chronicles and its sequels are some of my personal favorites to be placed alongside XCOM: Enemy WithinValkyria Chronicles is a tactical game like the aforementioned XCOM games but takes place in a setting not unlike that of World War II Europe. The setting is even called Europa, an antiquated name for Europe. It plays similar to XCOM in that you control a division of soldiers in various battlefields.

However, the major selling point of Valkyria Chronicles is its characters. Almost every soldier on the side of the protagonists has a name, a unique appearance and a personality to match. Some of the most memorable ones would probably be the friendly but tough gay guy and the crazy one-eyed flower shop owner. Every one of them has a unique motivation for joining the military as is often the case in real life. But, due to the fact that the story takes place in a time of war, the death of some characters is simply unavoidable and, believe me, if you’ve played the game and enjoyed it you will miss them.

I must say that this game reminded me all too much of what our military and police forces have to endure to keep our country safe and orderly. Unlike most strategy games, Valkyria Chronicles shows that every soldier is unique and every life is precious. While war is sometimes necessary to protect those we love, it can often be very terrible and that no one can ever really be considered expendable.

Samurai X

Despite what a certain egotistical tikbalang who thinks it’s being funny at your local TV station might say, this is, hands down, one of the better shows out there. While the creator has certainly taken liberties with some of the historical facts, it’s still quite loyal to the kind of setting Japan was during the Meiji Restoration. The anime is kind of old now and most people seem to know the film trilogy a lot better but both are worth watching if you want to get a better idea of what Japan was like back when foreigners had a growing presence there and how politics actually works.

I don’t want to spoil anyone with details although most of you are probably aware of Kenshi Himura or Shishio “the mummy” already. History, I think is very important for any culture and showing the youth the correct one instead of presenting them with over-embellished and heavily biased stories will just ruin them in the long run. Take note that while many adult Filipinos (with childish minds) tend to scoff at animated shows like Samurai X or films adapted from animated shows (like the tikbalang mentioned above), Samurai X has proven to be a very informative show for Japanese and other nationalities who watch it compared to the many teleseryes that focus on social dysfunction we have in the Philippines.


10 Replies to “Alternative Media (Part 5): Subtle But Strong Messages”

  1. Schindler’s list is a good film. It is a story of a good Nazi , who saved Jews, during World War II.

    The man is a true hero , and a humanist…he may be a womanizer; but, it was the way he was…

    Nazism is the same as Islamic Radicalism…One is a political ideology. The other is a political/religious ideology.

  2. Amon Goeth is the same as any Islamic Radical , who behead innocent people…these people are serial murderers, hiding behind a religious/political ideology…they are mentally ill.

  3. What drives people is definitely the things they bore witness to. Jose Rizal as a child was deeply affected by the Gomburza execution. Which drove him to do what he did growing up.

    As for recommended media, besides Berserk, there’s other few works whose messages just get to you because of how it was delivered.

    Animal Farm – The book and the movie. And like 1984, its by George Orwell. The story is about a farm of animals who gets fed up with the treatment they receive by their human masters and so stage a revolution and take over the farm. It starts all nice and dandy but as time went on, the very revolutionaries that led the charge slowly become the very tyrannical monsters they sought to overthrow. The last scene of both the book and the movie drive this home.

    Sengoku Rance – this a peculiar strategy game. The story is about a guy named Rance, who is put into power by Nobunaga himself as he wants him to take over a few territories so him and his sister could live in relative peace. But Rance finds that boring and decides to do things his way and tries to take over Japan itself! This man is the epitome of zeal and vigor as he does whatever he pleases and no matter how ill-thought out it may seem, he makes it work. This game also noted for its addicting gameplay, excellent visuals, kickass music, and its large variety of characters… which seems too much… for an H Game.

    1. I honestly don’t recommend Rance as far as positive alternative media goes. Despite having a fun story and gameplay, the protagonist’s motivations and actions, for the most part, are mischievous at best to downright deplorable. He’s not exactly a good role model to impressionable Pinoys. So yeah, no on this one.

      There are more wholesome media that are set in the Sengoku era. Look for those.

      1. Why does media have to have a ‘wholesome’ message? You sound like those parent groups that burned rock albums and sanitised comic books in the 1950s.

        One of my favourite current shows is It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia, which chronicles the deplorable exploits of irredeemable characters – should I watch The Waltons instead?

        1. You have to take into account the mental maturity of the Filipino masses, which unfortunately isn’t much judging by how they are easily starstruck by people of power and fame. Shows like Philadelphia would be liked for all the wrong reasons.

          I’m not trying to baby anyone by making them watch Sesame Street or Teletubbies, but there’s a level of crassness in alternative media people shouldn’t cross, at least until they know how to read between the lines.

  4. I have watched Schindler’s List many times. A moving and thought provoking movie. Neeson plays his part to perfection.

  5. Why do the Joos always get to cry the loudest?They were given an entire country, just given it.Since 1945 their are other ethnicities that have been treated far worse.
    Cambodia under Pol Pot, Dharfur and Ruwanda.

    The Joos have become what tried to annihilate them.

    1. Yes, Roma (Sinti) people were also victimized by the Nazis along with homosexuals, Slavs and other people they didn’t like.

      While I like Schindler’s List, I believe the other victims of the Holocaust also deserve some attention too.

  6. Every day is lost in which we do not learn something useful. Man has no nobler or more valuable possession than time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.