Senator Zubiri resignation: Is it an admission of guilt?

Quite a number of Filipinos were shocked by the news that Senator Juan Miguel Zubiri had filed his resignation following allegations of electoral fraud during the 2007 senatorial elections. The move was a first in Philippine political history. There has been no Filipino public official on record who resigned out of delicadeza or shame in the past. Normally, any protest against a politician would either get drowned out by another fresh set scandal or get withdrawn from lack of evidence; the latter not for lack of witnesses who can corroborate but for lack of witnesses who can cut a good deal in exchange for coming out. And cutting a good deal is where the names Ampatuan and Bedol come in.

The allegations of cheating initiated by losing senatorial candidate Koko Pimentel reached a turning point after two high profile witnesses came out. Suspended Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao governor and Maquindanao massacre suspect, Zaldy Ampatuan and former election supervisor in Maguindanao, Lintang Bedol admitted that they acted as if they were members of “The Adjustment Bureau”. Unlike the movie in which members of an incognito mob are sworn to secrecy, Ampatuan and Bedol are not holding back on alleging who is the mastermind behind the “twisting of the fate” of the candidates during the elections.

Ampatuan and Bedol have publicly named former First Gentleman, Jose Miguel “Mike” Arroyo as the one who instructed them to “fix” the results against the senatorial candidates who were part of the opposition. People can be forgiven for thinking that there is something in it for those two “witnesses” who are themselves, also in trouble with the law. But I digress…

Zubiri insists that he is not guilty of cheating and even said that he did not ask anyone any favors. He also insists that he is as much a victim of the so-called election syndicates:

Zubiri, however, said that he did not ask anyone for any favor regarding the elections. “Ang inyong lingkod ay lalabas ding biktima noong botohang naganap noong 2007 (I am also a victim of the 2007 elections),” he said.

Resigning from their posts is something that many public officials who were embroiled in controversies in other countries have been known to do. In Japan for example, they change Prime Ministers like they change shirts. If it’s dirty and needs washing, they need to go. A public official who is involved in an imbroglio or who does not deliver his duties must resign without even waiting for any calls for him to do so. He does this to save face and it is part of their culture. The people readily accept this practice as normal and will likely not raise an eyebrow over the next one.

Most western nations use shame or guilt as an agent of social control. Mounting criticisms or protest by the general public against an unpopular act, can make by the public official resign from his post. Here in the Philippines, most Filipino public officials act like psychopaths because they do not seem to feel guilt or remorse for their wrongdoings. As mentioned in my previous article:

Psychopaths are said to be those who lack any true sense of guilt or remorse for harm they may have caused to others. Instead, they blame their behavior on someone else, or deny it outright. They lack moral bearing (in comparison with the majority of humans) and are unable to evaluate situations within a moral framework. They also have an inability to develop emotional bonds with other people.

Philippine society keeps trying to model its way of life based on the western model but we fail to grasp the fundamentals of what make Western society work. A lot of our public officials do not have a sense of guilt or do not feel remorse for not being able to fulfill their social obligations and for causing harm to the rest of society. They also blame their behavior on someone else, make all kinds of excuses and therefore do not feel accountable for their actions.

Added to the lack of sense of guilt or remorse, Filipinos in general are averse to giving a critical evaluation of our public officials based on their past performance. This is part of the reason why the public officials who are guilty of embezzling public funds or those who simply do not do their jobs to the best of their abilities still get re-elected or worse put on a higher ranking position like the presidency. There is no shame in having accomplished mediocre work because Filipinos just “let the matter slide” into pwede na yan (“that’ll do”) oblivion and hope that things will become better eventually.

Our false sense of hope has gotten us nowhere. I hear a lot of people say, “There is still hope for the Philippines” but until we develop a sense of shame or guilt, there is no hope for the Philippines. We do not like being criticized at all, whether it is a fellow Filipino or a foreigner doing the criticizing, Filipinos tend to lash out or dismiss the criticism as lacking in merit. We as a people, lack the ability to evaluate our circumstances or apply a bit of self-reflection.

Sadly, our religion also plays a big role in how we quickly remove our sense of quilt and shame. We have been made to believe that our “sins” are forgiven once we confess to a priest or a member of the Catholic Church; it is as if our conscience can be wiped clean of every abominable act — and then we are ready to do it all over again. There is no real sense of atonement or remorse after the confession but the cycle of dysfunctional behavior continues until it becomes part of our system. In short, a lot of Filipinos hide behind their religion as they continue their fraudulent activities. We often see a lot of households adorned with the images of saints and the members of the holy family. It makes some Filipinos believe that they are holy despite their unholy acts.

According to cultural anthropologist Ruth Benedict, shame arises from a violation of cultural or social values while guilt feelings arise from violations of one’s internal values. It may make sense that Filipinos do not feel guilty or shameful about fraudulent activities if we perhaps consider that our internal values may be flawed. Worse, there seems to be a highly developed unconscious justification for deceptive actions within the Filipino mind. What we value as a society seems to be more around saving face by way of acquiring material possessions, family connections and having a good time.

If we are to imitate the culture of shame by the Japanese or to genuinely adapt the western culture using guilt as an agent of social control, we need to develop a sense of responsibility for others and ourselves. The only way we can attain stability and progress is to honor our promises and value what is best for the whole society and ourselves in the long-term, and not just focus on trivial pursuits that only cater to instant gratification. In short, we just need to develop a conscience.

Juan Miquel Zubiri’s reason for resigning might have been personal but he did the country a favor by putting an end to another media circus, which the public has grown accustomed to. For some Filipinos, his move makes him look guilty and to a handful of Filipinos, his move might seem laudable on the outside but they are still wary of his motives. After all, this is the Philippines where the padrino system trumps all other systems in place.

print

Post Author: Ilda

In life, things are not always what they seem.

Leave a Reply

22 Comments on "Senator Zubiri resignation: Is it an admission of guilt?"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
BenK
Editor
In the US, we’ve lately had two congressmen “do the walk of shame” — most everybody’s heard of Anthony Weiner, and the other was some guy from Oregon who I honestly didn’t pay much attention to, I think it was another sex thing. There have been others before, of course. In all those cases, there was some period of trying to weasel out from whatever nasty accusations were being hurled against them, before they finally came around to saying, “Yes, I did…something…and I apologize.” Maybe they didn’t come right out and admit whatever it was they’re supposed to have done,… Read more »
AsiaWest
Guest

So even if he really didn’t do anything wrong in connection with the alleged electoral fraud, from my point of view, he’s done something very wrong now.

Unfortunately, this inspires confidence in neither the system nor Zubiri himself. Former Gen. Angelo Reyes did something similar in the past (although his was a bit more on the extreme.) It only left many more unanswered questions in many people’s minds.

Frank
Guest

Congressman Craigslist should probably be the example to follow. He resigned hours after the scandal broke.

BenK
Editor

You mean Senator “I have a wide stance” Larry Craig? He still went through the whole try-to-weasel-out-of-it process first, and he’d even been arrested for public indecency.

Osh
Guest

@BenK
hell YEAH!!! ever heard of the saying
“The wicked flee when no one is pursuing, But the righteous are bold as a lion”

OR

“The guilty flee but the innocent stand proud and strong as a lion”

if you are innocent you will fight honorably and true so to Juan Miguel Zubiri:

“fvck you Sir”

Hyden Toro
Guest

In Japan, it is your face, that you have to put value on…Integrity is foremost; it’s all you need in dealing with your business partners. Once, you lost face…nobody will deal with you anymore…
We in the Philippines…it’s crookedness with self-respect. Duplicity with honor…”kung makapal, ang mukha mo. A-asenso ka”…
Our values are already upside down. Sen. Zubiri has his own reason in resigning…we have to respect it…

AsiaWest
Guest
So even if he really didn’t do anything wrong in connection with the alleged electoral fraud, from my point of view, he’s done something very wrong now. Due to a lack of an objective criteria that would bring closure to many of our issues, the Philippines carries so much collective baggage right now. What “da Pinoy” masses tend to take as reliable criteria for objective truth are typically either hearsay, anecdotal evidence, TFC or ABiaS-CBN (especially to teleserye addicts), their “kumpares” or “kumares”, a gossiping co-worker, someone wearing yellow, their “kabits”, popular opinion, and other sensational media source all of… Read more »
Joe America
Guest
Very thought provoking article. I hope you accept comment from those branded on GRP as lying, manipulative, overly sensitive, clueless, gender biased persons. To BenK’s point, that the good ex-senator pointed the finger of blame at others as the reason for resigning, I would offer up that this is not a characteristic consigned only to Filipinos, and that, indeed, modern media and sound bite distortions are making this a way of life worldwide. It is too easy to snipe and gain attention and make an undermining accusation. For sure, you can bet that neither Democrats nor Republicans in the US… Read more »
Joe America
Guest
Perspectives from the sidelines: Justice Secretary Leila de Lima “We have to determine the extent of his knowledge. He may not have participated, but clearly he was a beneficiary. A beneficiary may either be completely innocent or he acquiesced to the commission of the fraud. We have to know the extent of his knowledge.” Zubiri counsel George Erwin Garcia: “[Senator Zubiri] declared before the Filipino people by way of a privilege speech in the Senate that he is resigning as a duly elected and proclaimed Senator of the Republic of the Philippines. It was a rare and commendable, historical and final… Read more »
trackback

[…] to resign was Senator Juan Miguel Zubiri who filed his resignation following allegations of electoral fraud during the 2007 senatorial elections. The move was a first in Philippine political history. There has been no Filipino public official […]

trackback

[…] Senator Juan Miguel “Migz” Zubiri, if we recall voluntarily resigned his position as Senator out of delicadeza (it seems) in mid-2011 after he was implicated in […]

wpDiscuz