The slide of Nokia and the future of Facebook

The once mighty Nokia seems to be on the brink, announcing in mid-June that it will be slashing 10,000 jobs over the next 18 months following falling sales and losses this year. This, from a company that once utterly dominated the mobile phone market and was convinced that touchscreen phones “won’t replace traditional phones” (with thanks to @artsamaniego). We know now that Nokia’s slide follows a failure to anticipate the onslaught of smartphonestouchscreen smartphones…

Smartphones of course are the cause of Nokia’s problems. It’s being crushed in the marketplace by Apple’s iPhone (AAPL) and phones running Google’e Android (GOOG) operating system.

The Nokia gaffe, is the equivalent of the famous claim allegedly made by former IBM CEO Thomas J Watson in 1943 that “there is a world market for maybe five computers” [NB: that quote has since been discredited as a myth]. Interestingly, Watson’s real contribution to IBM — and perhaps much of the corporate world — was his slogan “THINK” which the IBM culture internalised fully, and which became a ubiquitous feature in all company paraphernalia going down all the way to inspiring its successful line of notebook computers, the IBM ThinkPads.

With the benefit of hindsight, one can argue that it was IBM’s thinking ethos that accounted for its ability to survive and re-invent its way through decades of seismic industry paradigm shifts, not unlike the one Nokia is going through today.

Subscribe to our Substack community GRP Insider to receive by email our in-depth free weekly newsletter. Opt into a paid subscription and you'll get premium insider briefs and insights from us.
Subscribe to our Substack newsletter, GRP Insider!
Learn more

Then again, for every success story that lulls most of us into a false sense that every story has a happy ending, there are thousands of failures that have languished in history’s dustbins of obscurity. Just a short time ago, at the crest of the first Internet hype tsunami in the late-1990s, the craze was on-line retailing. Every “expert”, every “analyst”, and every “consultant” — and their dogs — pontificated about the demise of “bricks-and-mortar” enterprises which were supposedly going to be swept away by a wave of “New Economy” digital businesses with their “virtual storefronts” that would supposedly “cut the middleman out” and usher in a new age of low prices for the consumer.

None of these “experts”, of course, foresaw the Facebook and Twitter future where the main online activity wasn’t filling digital “shoppingcarts” but clicking on “Like” and “Share” buttons and “Re-tweeting” snippets of wisdom to a vast network shared by other modern-day philosophers.

But while it took decades before that mythical 1943 forecast was debunked, Nokia’s hubris was turned upside down within just three years. Indeed, just days before Facebook’s disastrous IPO, the social media giant topped up a $300 million cash offer with more than 21 million of its issued shares as currency to buy Instagram in a deal that would have place the photo-sharing startup’s value at more than $1 billion if Facebook’s $35 share price held after the IPO.

Then just like that, Facebook’s gloss was dulled by a market less-than-enthused by uncertainty around how much of its network could really be turned into money-in-the-bank — and, more specifically, around how much of the much-vaunted migration of users’ social media activity to smartphones Facebook is prepared to “monetise”.

The point therefore, is that “analysts” have pegged their sights on this supposedly anticipated massive ramp up of smartphone use for everything and anything worth living for — like the way they gushed about how online retailing was supposed to turn malls and main streets into museums by the middle of the noughties.

Social media as it had come to dominate how people experience the Web nowadays was nothing like anything these analysts had anticipated — or forecast for — back in 1999. So who’s to know what the next couple of years — or the next couple of months — hold for those who seek to “monetise” the Web?

Certainly not the “experts”.

7 Replies to “The slide of Nokia and the future of Facebook”

  1. That’s why I switched to an Android phone. Can’t help but get disappointed at how Nokia handled things. I was a fervent Nokia fanboy once, but after a few years and after reading about the company blundering on their N-Gage platforms, my interest in their phones declined.

  2. Not just Nokia, RIM also. The only reason I still own a Nokia handset is that, I feel nostalgic about it (and I still don’t have the budget to purchase another Android handset). The problems with these companies was that, they relied too much on their existing user-base to continually help them stem the tide of iOS and Android phones. They thought that they could get away without really pushing their R&D to come up with more innovative solutions to rival iOS and Android. Even with them merging with Microsoft, it was already too late. I think, both Nokia & RIM is now only famous here in South East Asia, but with the influx of more affordable yet highly-functional Android handsets (Samsung Galaxy Y, Huawei Ascend Y200, both around PHP6k), I don’t think Nokia wouldn’t last very long as the top mobile phone in the country.

  3. Nokia made all Lumias (WP) look like the N9 (meego), which garnered more attention than the sh?t that microsoft has.

    They also gave away their “offline maps” to other microsoft’s wp partners. Dumba55es.

    Killed all R&D of any OS that rivals microsoft.

    Microsoft finally avenges the defeat of windows mobile from symbian, after 10 years.

  4. I despise microsoft. But I do not want an IOS-Android world. S3 shows Samsung trying to break away from android and they also have their own operating system called Tizen.

  5. I rather the rest of the world went with Japan’s direction of powerful flip phones back in the day, not this smartphone garbage. Sadly, even there they’re starting to phase them out.

    I blame the iphone for popularizing this dumb form factor.

    1. I share your lamentations, Sid.
      I wish to have more of the likes of Sharp 007SH, a flip phone that doubles as a full touch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.