Does Prasertsri Kosin (a.k.a. ‘Koko Narak’) deserve to be deported from the Philippines?

There is some basis in what Thai national Prasertsri Kosin says about Filipinos, specially the part about the Philippines being home to a “dangerous” society and Filipinos being “afraid of one another” as well as the way his own Filipino friends are “also mistreated” presumably by other Filipinos.

These were among observations Kosin (who has been living and working in the Philippines over an undisclosed period) expressed as “Koko Narak” on Facebook using his rudimentary English skills. Not surprisingly, Kosin’s actions attracted an “undesirable alien” charge and is now in the process of being deported.

Prasertsri Kosin (a.k.a. 'Koko Narak')(Photo source: Koko Narak's Facebook profile.)
Prasertsri Kosin (a.k.a. ‘Koko Narak’)
(Photo source: Koko Narak’s Facebook profile.)
It is, of course, certainly difficult to excuse the other slurs and unfounded comments he makes about his “superior body” and how it may be infected by “the pignoy virus”. The key question here, however, is whether Kosin’s alleged crime actually caused injury or death. Philippine Immigration Law lists some criteria on which bases an alien may be deemed “undesirable”. Though the set of criteria includes various financial crimes, prostitution, and sedition, there seems to be nothing in that law that provides for insult or disrespect of Filipinos and their culture as cause for deportation on grounds of “undesirability”.

In any case, how does one measure the gravity of an expressed “insult” or show of “disrespect” to begin with? Different people interpret a message in different ways. A message involving a culturally-sensitive topic, for example, may be interpreted by different people over a range with bemusement on one end and serious personal offense on the other. Most likely it will depend on the size and health of the message recipient’s ego. People with unhealthy but big egos tend to quickly take offense.

It therefore seems that Kosin is being deported because a number of Filipinos (presumably those who reported him) felt “insulted” by Kosin’s words.

The subjectiveness of the notion of insult and this being a case study of how a message summarily deemed “insulting” to Filipinos is used as basis for punitive action is what makes the expat community in the Philippines a nervous lot. The following lament posted on the discussion thread How Easy Is It To Get Deported If You Are Not Filipino? on the online message board Philippines Expat Forum seems to encapsulate the general sentiment of the Philippines’ community of “resident aliens”…

What chance [do] we have if they will deport Alex Baldwin for an insult that he claimed was a joke Undesirable Alien Alec Baldwin Banned From the Philippines for a joke Alec Baldwin has been banned from entering the Philippines – just one day after the actor publicly apologized for joking about sex trafficking in the country. The country’s Bureau of Immigration has closed its borders to the star, according to a statement released by the government office on Thursday (21May09). Immigration Commissioner Marcelino Libanan says, “By being on the bureau’s blacklist, Baldwin is forbidden from entering the country as he is deemed an undesirable alien.”

In short, foreign residents in the Philippines are pretty much aware that simply harbouring an opinion of the Philippines could get them into serious trouble. In the case of Prasertsri Kosin, it is likely that a big enough proportion of the Filipino population would be insulted by his words. But that is precisely the point being made here. Is the answer to the question of whether or not the charge of “undesirability” will stick based on the percentage of Filipinos offended? Or will it be based on an evaluation grounded on clearly-defined criteria or rules?

‘Koko Narak’ has since posted a note of apology to Filipinos on Facebook.

print

Post Author: benign0

benign0 is the Webmaster of GetRealPhilippines.com.

Leave a Reply

60 Comments on "Does Prasertsri Kosin (a.k.a. ‘Koko Narak’) deserve to be deported from the Philippines?"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
mrericx
Guest

Will he deported back to his own country for insulting us through posting on facebook? The answer will be yes, thanks to the controversial Anti-Cybercrime Law in our country and that kind of act will be sued for an e-libel in spite that he’s telling the awful truth about the conditions of our country lately like Filipinos are being rude and undisciplined, issues on red tape and bad systems that we run here, corruption, etc. etc.

kaka
Guest

Open you eyes and you can see it.

I am foreigner leaving in makati.I always had very bad experienced with pinoy guys who I would like to make Friend or more relationship. When they ask me to meet each other, They are always asking me “treat me” “pay for me”, “I don’t have work, you should treat me? “you have work and hight salary, so better you pay” and ….. that make me feel bad with pinoy.

If you ask foreigner who are working here in Philippines. you will know it.

077Toro008Hayden
Guest

Aquino and his administration, are very sensitive to criticism…Filipinos are very sensitive , as a whole to criticism. It may be because, they have eyes, but refuse to see the Truth about them. They have ears, but they refuse to hear the Truth about them.

Truth hurts, but it is the truth. Why not accept the “opinion”, and make it as a guidepost for improvement? But, No…they are hurt, and they don’t want to hear the truth. Especially from a foreigner…so on you go – Deportation, for expressing opinions…

Gagong Lipunan
Guest

So much for being a democracy, then…

andrew
Guest

this is the problem with most Filipinos. they don’t want to hear and see what they REALLY NEED to hear and see. all they want is the validation from foreign people that Filipinos are great artists, etc. look around us filipinos, koko can be used as the eye for all of us.

I don’t blame him because what he said is true. probably here in metro manila only. if I would talk this guy, I would say that he should have been more specific: the pignoys of metro manila.

chad
Guest

I thought we Filipinos are very expressive of our feelings and sentiments, and that was precisely what we have inherited from the 1986 EDSA Revolution, and same revolts thereafter. What is the power of the bill of rights, particularly that of freedom of speech, of expression, and of the press, for? His personal comment does not endanger national security, public safety and order, therefore should not be abridged.

Jason Matthew "Gwapo" Bautista Alamar
Guest
Jason Matthew "Gwapo" Bautista Alamar

Wala yang Thailander na yan dapat diyan binabartulina bago sipain pabalik ng gay country nya. Dun sya bagay sa mga kauri nyang bakla

Ricardo_Diaz
Guest

So the really stupid Anti-Cybercrime law has passed… Congratulations Philippines. You just taught people how to post anonymously.

But in relation to the topic, Filipinos get too easily offended by little things and it in turn doesn’t allow them to mature into proper adults. Because as sad as it may sound, pain is necessary for growth and maturity. So if you try and wall yourself off, it will fail spectacularly.

Such as the case we see today.

DR
Guest

Just shows how vain and thin skinned these people are. They cant take criticism of any kind even though they live in a third world country.

tina
Guest

see how you state your case with the intent to insult at the end. this is an example of our thought of “intelligence” has changed.

nati
Guest

Ride on sister! Intelligent people say what is and what isn’t! If you think otherwise, you just can’t accept the truth…and you’re just butthurt! And what’s even crazier is that they call you Filipino!

Ang Galing…….mang-asar!

Berto
Guest

there’s objective criticism and then there’s insults. that guy clearly did the latter. i may not agree with the punishment but that guy was a real dick. add another +100 damage for that chickenshit apology. at least have some balls to stand by what you said when the climate was still comfortable for you.

not sure
Guest

Stick and stones… This is going too much for silencing opinions.

nagtatanong_lang
Guest

better complete the rhyme for those who are not familiar with it..

Sticks and stones may break my bones
But words will never hurt me.

something to think about for those who are easily hurt by mere taunts

KVillaralvo
Guest

Filipinos are simply not mature enough to take responsibility for their emotions. When they feel hurt, it’s always someone else’s fault. A mature person would not bother with those things because he is too busy working for his success. Isn’t this how Singapore succeeded, the way they didn’t give a rat’s ass about what other people say about them?

tina
Guest

So are you mature enough to be here reading posts and commenting on posts like this? You aint busy working for success? I don’t think so, right?

mei
Guest

Just so you know, Singaporeans are quite sensitive too. Try googling for the case of the Filipino nurse and the British Anton Casey.

superlucky20
Guest

Yeah, the people here act as if being offended by foreigners is exclusive to Filipinos.

Jetlag807
Guest

In the FREE WORLD, freedom of speech is respected and protected. In countries like North Korea, China and the Philippines, there is no such thing. Freedom of speech, like any Philippine Law, does not apply to “foreigners”. This place is a joke!

Prakash
Guest
If a fellow Filipino said exactly the same thing, other Filipinos, I reckon, if not all, will either laugh or shrug the insults off (i.e. ganyan talaga mga Pilipino…). But it often stings when this sort of words comes from others. I don’t buy into Kosin’s actions. At the same time, I’m inclined to think of what prompted him to say those in the first place and whether there’s a grain of truth in his diatribes. Is there anything we can learn from it? As a Filipino myself, destructive small talks about other Filipinos are commonplace, e.g. how incompetent others… Read more »
tina
Guest
people here seemed to be confused with the difference of “insult” and constructive criticism. if you state the negative truth to belittle people, it is NOT RIGHT for any civilized person. there is what we call “social responsibility”. when you highlight one’s weakness to put them down…it is NOT RIGHT therefore not tolerable. If you criticize, without providing a suggestion, then your intent is to hurt. That is NOT RIGHT. of course it is not right as well to lambast him, people who did that is just as worse as him. if we accept these behaviors, then we set a… Read more »
Pascual Delgado Jr.
Guest

I agree with the Mr. benign0. Let us extend our apologies to Mr. Narak for “much ado about nothing”. With the publicity he will get he might become a movie star! I’m all ups to Mr. Narak staying in the Philippines with all the freedom to walk our streets, lanes and avenues.

sweetscrazy
Guest

If ALL things were set in clearly defined rules, then there would be an un-ending list of rules. It would be a perpetual burden both on the rule-makers and the people. The lack of clearly defined rules for moral behavior is simply and naturally addressed by common sense and morality. You’ve wasted your time writing this piece just as I’ve wasted a minute writing this comment.

Falerea
Guest

There are people systeatically insulting the British, the French, the Americans or the Russians everywhere in the web. However, they are not being expelled from those countries because they are intelligent enough to ignore them. The ‘persona non grata’ policy is ridiculous.

ElYebay
Guest

Im a filipino living here in the philippines. What does it take for one to get deported from this hellhole?

olx
Guest

It only takes your common sense and you ready for the US of A! A for Asshole!

Sick Amore
Guest

So there’s a chance Dan Brown can’t set foot in the Philippines after depicting Manila to be the gates of hell even if Bourne Legacy supported his claim and a lot of Pinoys were happy to be part of the film and can relate to the portrayal in the novel?

mrericx
Guest

I can’t wait if Inferno will become a live action film & it’ll shoot here in our country. Mr. Hanks you’ll gonna love this country for sure as long as you’ll gonna accept the harsh reality of this country like traffic, crimes, undisciplined people and corruption.

Sick Amore
Guest
Actually there’s no need for you to wait. The live action is happening around you from time to time. Honestly, I wanted him to elaborate his comment. I’m curious why he chose the term Pignoy? It’s the first time I heard of it. Does he know about the Filipinos march against Pork Barrel thievery? Is he seeing pigs whenever he saw faces of Filipino (politicians)? “wriggling cockroaches prisoned by Baygon” He must have seen a scenario in the Philippines depicting this. I wonder where. “your society is dangerous” “people in your country are afraid of one another” Apart from the… Read more »
pearl bethany
Guest
Omigosh, yes, Benigno. You should know that in some of our barrios, one gets to “find himself dead in the kankungan” just because he looks “siga” to some men there, or his car or motorcycle “damaged” because it looks like “pasikat” to them…..OMG!!!! I wanted to take a pic of our profs’ situation in the PRC, applying for prof license or renewing….either way…they sit on the stairs, on the floor, some (when so many) standing in front of the building, rain or shine regardless…..and publish it a national daily so that many of us will know, and to catch the… Read more »
Dave
Guest

It’s always entertaining scrolling through the irate knee-jerk Pinoy Pride reactions on news sites.

The funniest was a Filipino asking what foreigners are doing working in this country in the first place, stealing jobs from Filipinos. Second funniest was a Filipino criticizing Thailand’s cuisine.

Dick S. O'Rosary
Guest

Its not just our ego that we have to deal with. We also have this pesky coping mechanism called “utang na loob”.

When we allowed this guy into the country, we, as Filipinos already assume that we did him a favor and he owes us back.

This is a completely backward and provincial coping mechanism since everything in our society ends up revolving around “favors”: politics, business, foreign affairs and what not.

Grimwald
Member

This is an off-hand comment but…

From the way he likes to take selfies of himself just makes what he did even more atrocious. This is why I rarely post pictures of myself, if ever.

tomas
Guest

lol! you got a point there.

wpDiscuz