Prosecution misled the public when they alleged CJ Corona had 45 properties

Just when most people thought it was going to be another boring day of presentation of documents by the defense counsels, a bombshell hit the impeachment court during the trial of Chief Justice Renato Corona. Even with the absence of defense lead counsel Serafin Cuevas, crushing the allegations of the prosecution was just a walk in the park for the rest of the defense team.

Tupas misled the public when he alleged Corona owned 45 properties.

Even as private prosecutor Jose Justiniano snickered as he objected to the laborious testimony of the witness from the Land Registration Authority (LRA), no one from the prosecution team realized that some of the Senator Judges were listening intently to the presentation of the evidence — which is probably why they were caught off guard when those Senators questioned their motives in releasing what is now clearly the wrong information that Chief Justice Corona owned 45 properties. By then the defense had made it quite evident that only five of those can be directly linked to the Chief Justice.

LRA Administrator Eulalio Diaz III, who gave the list of the properties to the prosecutors was heavily admonished by a few Senators who were shocked to find out that he (1) acted on an informal request done over the phone by Congressman and lead prosecutor, Niel Tupas, Jr; (2) released a list of properties supposedly under Corona’s name without checking if the list was accurate; (3) inadvertently divulged private information concerning other individuals who are not even involved in the trial; and (4) adopted a “cavalier” attitude towards his own gaffe.

Apart from the above, LRA administrator Diaz, a former classmate of President Noynoy Aquino, was unapologetic when Senators Jinggoy Estrada, Joker Arroyo, Pia Cayetano and Loren Legarda kept asking him why he released documents without checking them. Diaz simply blamed their department’s computer system for the inclusion of a few individuals unrelated to the case, including former Quezon City Mayor Ismhael Mathay who is not even related to the Coronas. Diaz also insinuated that it was not his job to check the accuracy of the list — a list that came from their department – but the prosecutor’s.

I’ll give Diaz half a point for his half-assed excuse because the prosecutors led by Congressman Tupas should have combed through the list before presenting it to the court as evidence and especially before presenting it to the media during their trial by publicity. When asked to explain, Tupas tried to throw the ball back onto Diaz by saying that they relied on the accuracy of the list. Tupas also denied misleading the public and justified presenting it as evidence because, according to him, he just wanted to know the truth. But the truth, it seems, is that he and the rest of the prosecution team just wanted Chief Justice Corona to resign by damaging his credibility.

I’ve said it before but I’ll say it again: the prosecution and their cohorts probably think that the Filipino people, including their Senators, are stupid. What were they thinking when they alleged that Corona had 45 properties when in fact, documents that are also available from the LRA indicate that 17 were cancelled titles? Did they actually think that the defense would miss that important piece of information just as they had missed it? It’s amazing how the whole thing flew over their heads considering they have all the available resources including most government agencies and a stealth army of “small ladies” at their disposal. They even have the backing of the President himself, for goodness sake. Obviously, even investigative journalists like Raissa Robles and those at Rappler.com could not help them with the facts. It’s probably because they are not used to handling real data.

I used to think the prosecution was incompetent. Now I think they are also hopeless. The problem is, most people tend to believe what the prosecution are saying. This is evident in the new survey released by survey firm Pulse Asia, a firm said to be owned and operated by friends and family members of PNoy. According to the survey, 33% think that Corona is probably guilty and 15% think he is guilty. In the same survey, it says 56% of Filipinos know only a little about the issue.

Whether the result of the survey is accurate or not, the real question is: Who would sponsor a survey while the impeachment trial is still ongoing and more importantly, for what purpose? It is worth noting that the result was published a day after PNoy promised to stop commenting on the trial. His minions probably decided that sending subliminal messages to the public is much better for his image.

Now the impeachment trial of Chief Justice Renato Corona may just prove the theory that suggests, “incompetent people are unable to judge the competence of other people, or the quality of those people’s ideas.”

According to a new study, democracy may not work in societies where the majority is “just too stupid to pick the right candidate.” We already know that statement to be true with the biggest proof in the underachieving former Senator, Noynoy Aquino winning the presidential election in 2010. The study also explained the reason why the wrong leaders keep getting voted in:

“…a growing body of research has implied that democratic elections produce mediocre leadership and policies.

For example, if people lack expertise on tax reform, it is very difficult for them to identify the candidates who are actual experts. They simply lack the mental tools needed to make meaningful judgments.

As a result, no amount of information or facts about political candidates can override the inherent inability of many voters to accurately evaluate them.

[Cornell University psychologist] Professor [David] Dunning said: “Very smart ideas are going to be hard for people to adopt, because most people don’t have the sophistication to recognise how good an idea is.”

If you change the words of the above statement to what is happening now during the impeachment trial, you will come up with something like this: If people lack the expertise on law or the interpretation of the constitution, it is very difficult for them to identify the lawyers or judges who are actual experts. The majority of Filipinos simply lack the mental tools to make meaningful judgements.

This, unfortunately, is the dilemma in our society that is evident now. It seems that regular folks can only understand simple statements such as “Chief Justice Corona betrayed the public trust”. But when the defense counsels try to prove the allegations are wrong using facts and data, most people including some senators, roll up their eyes or glaze over because it becomes too technical for them. Journalists certainly find it “boring”.

Explaining a simple concept is like having a root canal because even senators themselves cannot comprehend what some of the counsels and experienced former regional court judges are saying. Their lack of understanding of the law and their own biases against Chief Justice Corona frustrates or bores some of them when they are listening to the painstaking defense presentations. It seems they consider “hearsay” information more exciting. If the senators cannot understand the rule of law, what more can we expect from regular Filipinos?

How in the world will the senators come to a decision? There is simply no meeting of the minds, which is why the trial does not progress at a quicker pace. The guideline on how to fill up the SALN form for example cannot be agreed upon. Defense is saying that the “constitutional provision on the SALN did not require more stringent guidelines for the Chief Justice and other magistrates of the Supreme Court than any other public official.”

They even pointed out that “the Civil Service Commission recently announced that it would issue a new SALN form which would require specific entries–proof that the current SALN did not require detailed information.” However, the prosecution is simply insisting that “Corona betrayed the public trust” when he did not include some assets in his SALN. Never mind that the evidence already proves that Corona didn’t have to because some properties that were alleged to be his do not belong to him.

The bottom line is, the senator judges seem to have conflicting ideas about what should be the guideline in coming up with a decision. Sometimes they quibble on matters such as determining when the property should have been included in the SALN to trivial ones such as whether a witness is still relevant or not. It’s just so amazing that everyone talks like an expert while knowing very little about what they are talking about. It is becoming apparent though that all the confusion can be traced to the prosecution’s presentation of false evidence and violation of the law, something that should be grounds for the immediate dismissal of the impeachment case.

[Photo courtesy Sunstar.com.ph.]

print

Post Author: Ilda

In life, things are not always what they seem.

Leave a Reply

187 Comments on "Prosecution misled the public when they alleged CJ Corona had 45 properties"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
crude
Guest

Yes, this prosecution booboo is really, really off putting. Talaga ngang bobo, defense had a heyday pointing that out.

But then again, this is oh soooo last month? I thought I was reading a back issue of GRP.

leaf
Guest
we had a conversation of my colleague just a few minutes ago.. if those people were truly concerned to the Filipino pipz, then its so unfair that CJ Corona is the hottest subject matter of not declaring the right SALN but of course, we all know that even a little business man is not declaring right TAX of his own company, di ba? parang hello, ask your self na lang, halos lahat even yan mga senators na yan.. di ka panipaniwala na sila mismo nagdedeclare ng tama sa lahat ng pag aari nila, kung dumi lang ang titignan natin sa… Read more »
leaf
Guest

this trial! you know what? mas lalong nagkakabaha bahagi ang mga Filipino, just look down na lang sa comment ng mga taong yun, konti na lang magsabunutan.. buti na lang di face to face to..

ninfa macansantos
Guest

Manners r of more importance than laws.Upon them,in a great measure,d laws depend.D laws touch us but here & there,& now & then.Manners are what vex or soothe,corrupt or purify,exalt or debase,barbarize,or refine us,by a constant,steady,uniform,insensible operation,like that of the air we breathe in.-E.Burke

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

Nagsinungaling p rin si Corona sa kanyang SALN at hnd p pnapaliwanag ang kanyang peso at dollar account. At mrmi p rin ang naniniwalang guilty si Corona dhl sya ay tuta ni Gloria s knyang mga plano. Hbang buhay na ang khhyan s buhay nya, dpat mgbitiw o mtnggal n sya sa pwesto.

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

MpapatUNAYan yn s kmaganak ni Corona n mga Basa. Glit n glit sila dhl ninakaw ang pera n dpt sknla

Eduardo Penalosa
Guest

eh bobo ka pala, wala kang alam dak dak ka pa. ang mga katulad mong pulpol ay ang sumisira ng bansa na ito. Mali anag katwiran walang kalatuy latuy.

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

Si Corona ang sumisira ng bnsa dhl para syang robot na sunod lng ng sunod sknyang amo n si Gloria, at ang asawa nya n nkasuhan ng estafa.

DaidoKatsumi
Guest

@Vincenzo:

Si Noynoy ang sumisira sa bansa because he always wasting time chasing and villifying his political enemies…

while doing NOTHING.

Oh yeah, do you know Carpio? Well, robot din siya na sunud-sunod din kay Abnoy pag napaalis na si Corona. Ironic, isn’t it?

Mirror Force
Guest
Kung ang basehan lang sa pagtanggal kay Chief Justice Corona ay public opinion (of what, 2000-something people when in truth you will have to account for a universe of 90-million-strong Filipinos wanting to be heard)… ayos, ba’t pa tayo may impeachment court? Besides, papaano mo masasabing nagsinungaling si Chief Justice Corona sa kanyang SALN? Have you any evidence to prove it? He who alleges has the burden of proof, hindi ‘yung ngawa ka lang ng ngawa diyan. (Well, kung tutuusin, ang mga ebidensiyang inihain ng mga prosecutor ay isa-isa namang dinidismantilya ng matino’t masusing presentasyon ng defense counsels… wala kasing… Read more »
Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

Ikw ang wlang utak, bkt my TRO sa hold departure order ni Gloria smantalang npkrmi p nyang kaso tungkol s pgnanakaw at pndraya? At tgnan m si Gloria, maayos naman ang kondisyon nya pero cnb nya dti mamamatay n sya? Mgksbwat itong dalawang ito

Eduardo Penalosa
Guest

uy pumapalag ang bobo. mali naman ang pangangatwiran. Dapat naging prosecutor ka, bobo ka rin pala. Alam mo naman ayaw mo lang aminin. Hahaha.

domo
Guest

Aba aba aba grabe ka lumaban ah. Ganyan ka na ba ka-hostile dahil ayaw mo lang magpatalo vincensus ignoramus?

Felipe
Guest

Wala naman charge nuon na-issue yun TRO. Dapat lang ipaglaban ang karapatan ng tao. Lalo na’t lumalabas pa ngayon na ala palang basehan yun mga pinagsasabi nila AbNoy. Mag-noynoying ka nalang gayung ala rin naman kayong silbi.

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

Bobo, tngn m dpat pang bgyan ng krapatan si Gloria mtapos nyang mgnakaw ng bilyon bilyon sa kaban ng bayan?

Anonymous
Guest

@vincenzo
MY REACTION TO YOUR POST:

Felipe
Guest
@Vincenzo B. Arellano Bobo, tngn m dpat pang bgyan ng krapatan si Gloria mtapos nyang mgnakaw ng bilyon bilyon sa kaban ng bayan? Sarili mo dapat ang murahin mo. Matauhan ka naman. Mga programa na inumpisahan ni Gloria, inaako ni abNoy. Magkaibigan dati sila Gloria at ang mag-inang sila Cory at abNoy. Si abNoy pa ang nagsabing wag patugtugin ang “Hello Garci” tapes. Kinaaway nalang nila Cory si Gloria nuong pinabibigay yun Hacienda Luisita sa mga kawawang magsasaka. Karapatan ng magsasaka ang ipinaglaban ni Gloria at ayaw nila Cory yun. Meron akong takot na nasusunog na sa impyerno kaluluwa ni… Read more »
Eduardo Penalosa
Guest

eh gaga ka pala, hindi pa tapos ang depensa,anong paliwanag ang hinahanap mo. Mahina talaga ang utak mo, wala ka bang isip o bobotante ka?

dabedabs
Guest

how can you say na tuta xa?

Der Fuhrer
Guest

@Nutzi Vincenzo

Your statements are nothing but rants. All without evidence and just pure black propaganda sprinkled with trial by publicity. Der grobe Fuhrer of the palace by the river must be proud of you!

Lord Chimera
Guest

Ah its you Mr.Vincenzo, how nice of you to show up and entertain us with antics and stupidity. But why do show yourself rarely? After all we need a jester to lighten up our days.

Anonymous
Guest

His rare appearances only mean one thing…
He is getting really really butt hurt on how the trial is not swaying in his tito noy’s favor, and now that the palpaksecution has been unmasked as LIARS… He resorts to posting really lame and really stupid rants here.

Eduardo Penalosa
Guest

It seems at this point in the trial, only the $ accounts remain to be explained. Now what is sickening is the thought that should the CJ be pronounced guilty, it would be bec. illegally obtained documents won the day for the prosecution. In short, the hero will be the unbelievable ghost small lady or the equally unbelievable ghost who put those bank records in the gate of Cong. Banal. What a travesty of justice and what a farce.

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

Dyan ngagalit ang taumbyan dhl kung wlang syang ksalanan dpat una plang ipinakta n nya ang dollar account. My tntago ksi.

Felipe
Guest

Di naman kanya yung $, kaya tama lang na hindi isama sa trial na kalokohan na iyan. Magaling kayo sa gawa-gawa lang—hanggang kathang-isip na telenobela lang kayo magaling…hahaha.

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

bkt pnaTRO nya ang subpina ng dollar account nya my tntago itong si Corona cgro mga ninakaw nla ni Gloria

Felipe
Guest

@Vincenzo B. Arellano

bkt pnaTRO nya ang subpina ng dollar account nya my tntago itong si Corona cgro mga ninakaw nla ni Gloria

SC ang nag-desisyon nun sinasabi mo—Ala na si Corona nun. Parati naman napapatunayan na mali yang mga akala nyo. Puro kayo akala—maraming namamatay sa akala.

Puro kayong mga labag sa 8th commandment. Hindi talaga kayo maka-Diyos—Puro kasi kayong maka-demonyong Aquino. Trabaho ng demonyo yang mag-akusa—puro kayo mga ‘false witnesses’—ala rin naman palang alam.

Delikado na yang amo mong si anak ng Tupas na yan.

Eduardo Penalosa
Guest

Alam mo malaki ang depekto ng pangangatwiran mo, hindi mo ba napapansin? Ikaw yung tipong may husga na kahit di pa tapos ang trial. Kulang ka pa sa information pero dli dali kang nagsasalita. Ngayon din lang ako nakipag sagutan sa isang mahina ang ulo at mali amg opinyon. Proud ka siguro na mababaw kang mangatwiran.

Vincenzo B. Arellano
Guest

Bka ikw ang mhna ang ulo dhl hnd m alam ang mlalim n pgsasama ni Corona at Gloria, at hnd m rin alam n mrming pgnanakaw ang gnwa nla hnd lng s taumbyan kundi pati sa sariling kmaganak

Julian Cruz
Guest

Vicenzo, ano naman ang proweba mo sa pagsasama ng dalawa? Malapit ka ba sa mga Corona at mga Arroyo? Kung wala kang proweba, manahimik ka na lang.

Philip
Guest

Mr Vincenzo, frequent reader ka ba ng GRP blogs? Isa ka kasi sa mga tinatawag na squatter mentality. kung hindi mo alam ibig sabihin nun, try mo basahin ung mga previous posts dito. tama nga ung isang nagpost dito, dapat sumama ka sa prosecution team. mga katulad mo ang dahilan kung bakt hindi umuunlad ang bansa.

Julian Cruz
Guest

Kaya sa 2013, matalo sana lahat ng tatakbo sa liberal party.

Anonymous
Guest

yep, frequent reader dito si vincenzo at frequently din siya napapahiya dito.

Considered as the VILLAGE IDIOT si Vincenzo

Aegis-Judex
Guest

Speaking of Village Idiots… the Philippines looks like it’s a country of village idiots.

cool ass
Guest

some people has nothing to say but they keep on talking anyway 🙂

sa sobrang dada, nakikita tuloy na walang laman ang tiny brainy nya, hahaha

Felipe
Guest

Benigno Simeon Aquino III (aka ‘BS Aquino’ or simply ‘abNoy’) has betrayed public trust by being part of lies that (true to his usual form) wasted government time and resources.

jay
Guest

which prosecutor is building a 100 million peso house and is taking delivery if a top of the range mercedes SUV. no wonder he is always grinning.
check his saln next year

Der Fuhrer
Guest

I saw a picture of the sleeping president. This was posted in the upper left corner of the headlines section of the Philippine Star today(March 21, 2012).
It showed him bending to carry what appears like a small stack of folders containing documents for meetings at the palace. He was obviously posing for a photo shoot. All this to give the impression that he is not our lazy leader. What happened to the assistants who carry this for the P-rex and arrange this on the conference table? Obviously anti-noynoying propaganda. It’s more fun in the Philipines!

DaidoKatsumi
Guest
@Vincenzo said: ‘Bobo, tngn m dpat pang bgyan ng krapatan si Gloria mtapos nyang mgnakaw ng bilyon bilyon sa kaban ng bayan?’ Before you say that to our faces, take a look at yourself; dapat ba bigyan ka ng karapatan kahit marami kang nagawang kasalanan sa mga magulang mo, kaibigan mo, etc.? What if we say no? Sabi ni Optimus Prime: “Freedom is the right of all sentient beings.” So ibig sabihin, kahit ako may kasalanan, does that mean that I should not have the right to defend myself or to treat me kindly? Should I be deprived of any… Read more »
K3
Guest

Misled? Yes.
Intentionally? I don’t think so.
I don’t think they’re good enough to do that. I think they’re like a bunch of kids who accidentally dropped a piece of mentos into a glass of coke and wanted to tell everyone of their “discovery”.

paul
Guest
“incompetent people are unable to judge the competence of other people, or the quality of those people’s ideas.” might i add also that incompetent people are unable to fathom the reasons behind other people’s actions and therefore are quick to judge them as unethical, immoral or whatever other adjective there is for what they think is unacceptable or inappropriate behavior.case in point is how many thought it was too rash for senator santiago to hurl the word gag* towards the unequivocably incompetent prosecution. what people fail to see, is how insulted senator santiago must have been, a seasoned senator and… Read more »
jay
Guest

what we are seeing is the kindergarten of politics.
a joke for western professionals, but far worse, an insult to the country.

Trosp
Guest

What can you expect.

Right from the start of his term, Penoy is governing as if he is a president of student council.

A shameless president…

Trosp
Guest

He he he I think everything have been said already in this thread.

I can only say “the way these idiots’ minds work…”

And Vincenzo is the lite version of one of phony commenters here.

K3
Guest

But I love vincenzo’s eccentricities, such as calling the president “Tito”

Does that mean I would love more everyone else’s quirks? XD

Trosp
Guest

No dull moments every time he’s around.

Nutus
Guest

You actually mean Trosp is only a distant second to Vincenzo?!

At least Trosp can construct passable English.

Amir Al Bahr
Guest

The senator judges, as a body, are now presented with a “dilemma”. If they continue the trial, then they are accepting that they do not care being misled by the prosecution. If they don’t, the childish brat one-trick PNoy will only throw perhaps his most monumental tantrum to date.

jay
Guest

i hope you realise ‘vincenzo’ is an organisation not a person. its obvious enough from the postings – different spellings, different tones etc. i.e a number of people on ‘shift’ and posting under different names on other sites.
malacanan ‘outsourcing’ trolling

ahehe
Guest

America has a sock puppet software. Maybe the Palace is using a lite version. Third world edition.

Philip
Guest

Tupas might have beat Pinocchio already for redefining “lying”.

crude
Guest

Pero di pa rin niya ma-beat si Corona, si Gloria at si Mike Arroyo e. Siguro, mga nine years pa 🙂

anton
Guest

I knew it! You are a PNoy supporter.

Sabi ko na nga ba you are just discouraging the writers from writing about the prosecution. Buko ka na!

crude
Guest

Hehehe, anti-Arroyo ako pero di ako pro-Pnoy. Ganoon lang ba kaliit ang mundo mo?

Daido Katsumi
Guest

The Aquinos are the worst. Mga 50 years iyon, including the infamous Mendiola and Hacienda Luisita Massacres.

I smell hypocrisy here.

crude
Guest

That was 50 years ago and you still have that baggage?!

Corona just pointed a gun on a hapless caretaker just a good 13 years ago.

Hmmm…..hypocrisy, two can play that game.

Daido Katsumi
Guest

@crude: Yes, the Aquino-Cojuangco clan is much a bigger fish comapared to the Arroyos and even Corona. The fullness of that corruption started after Marcos left. Just saying

And why the hell did you get that? Source for the record or it’s all just hearsay, idiot. Or worse, Chewbacca defense.

crude
Guest

“And why the hell did you get that?”

pardon?!

crude
Guest

Like duh?!

Daido Katsumi
Guest

@crude: You said that Corona pointed a gun against a caretaker 13 years ago. Is THAT relevant? Can you give me the source.

Vindictive malicious troll on the leash.

crude
Guest

Like…..Duh?!

A.A
Guest
nung pinapanood ko si LRA Baboy Tanga Bwi**t Diaz kahapon, parang gusto ko nang magpakamatay! Kasi parang wala na akong nakikitang magandang bukas. Tayo ay napapaligiran, at (worst)pinapamahalaan ng mga gago at incompetent na mga tao. At dito na nga lang sana ako nakapagpahinga sa GRP (salamat sa mga matitinong bloggers) nasundan pa ako ng “vincenzo” na yellowtard. Hoy vincenzo (o mga vincenzo), basahin mo nga ng matino ang mga posts ng mga bloggers dito at ikumpara mo dun sa inyo. Wag ka nga dito. Di mo ka-level ang mga tao dito. And sa mga bloggers d2, please, wag nyo… Read more »
Philip
Guest

yup, kitang kita sa manner ng mga comments, kung sino yellowtard, at kung sino nasa matinong pagiisip. member nga kasi ng SM (squatter mentality) si vincenzo. ok nga tong blogging site, marerealize mo na yung mga lumalabas sa media eh “not always what they seem”.

Der Fuhrer
Guest

Add one more to the growing list…

It is now an instrument of public policy to intentionally mislead the public in the Senate Impeachment Trial.

Lord Chimera
Guest
Is there any point to this whole impeachment exercise? For starters this was never about justice or fighting corruption but the gratification of the whims and desire of the King in Yellow, second the prosecution team has been very blatantly lying ever since day one. In fact one has to question if we even have to go on with these whole dance. Even if one could overlook the first reason the second reason cannot be ignored. If the senators continue with the whole dance it shows that they are letting themselves be taken for fools with the lies the prosecution… Read more »
Daido Katsumi
Guest

Let’s trash it to the garbage and let Corona be acquitted. This is all part of Noynoy’s scheme against his political enemies. Only fools who are gullible enough to believe in this kind of nonsense guised as his ‘anti-corruption’ campaign. The prosecution panel are more like politicians than lawyers.

As of now, I can consider any ‘anti-corruption’ campaign as trivial matters. It can easily sway the mindless masses because the media keeps telling them that corruption is ‘pagnanakaw sa kaban ng bayan’ BS. It’s simple: it’s more than that.

Der Fuhrer
Guest

The prosecution really misled the public…
“45 Corona houses fixed at 5.”

http://www.malaya.com.ph/03212012/news1.html

jeanne
Guest

guy had the gall to cleanse himself of all the fualts. even says that the day was a waste. Personally, it’s not. At elast i saw how competent aquino’s men are. Or perhaps incompetent.