It feels like the mid-2000s again, when the “force” of the “people’s will” was being invoked to trump the outcomes of institutionally-governed procedure. The funny thing about the call to overrule institutional rule today is that those who are sounding off the “people power” siren are supporters of the incumbent Philippine President Benigno Simeon ‘BS’ Aquino III.
When this nebulous notion of the “people’s will” (disembodied from institutions and due process) was first called upon in 1986 (against then President Ferdinand Marcos) then re-hashed in the mid-2000s (against then President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo), those making that call were in the Opposition. Bizarrely those who make that call today are aligned with the man in power. And, this time, it is a call pitting the Executive Branch against the Judicial Branch under the premise that the Supreme Court in its ruling that President BS Aquino’s Disbursement Acceleration Program (DAP) is unconstitutional is wrong. And following the logic further, because people perceive that ruling as “wrong” and no longer serves the interests of “the people”, well, it’s time that “people power” be called upon again to supplant it.
I recall an article I wrote back in 2005, when a bid to impeach then President Arroyo on charges of electoral fraud failed to pass Congress. Interestingly it was a little guy in the then Opposition familiar to all of us now that was wailing and gnashing his teeth…
“Saan tayo pupunta pagkatapos pag wala na yung impeachment complaint?” (“Where do we go if the impeachment complaint is voted down?”) asked former education secretary and Liberal Party leader Florencio “Butch” Abad. This was echoed in the PCIJ Blog article “A Black-and-White Day” further quoting Abad: “What path do people take once the impeachment option is slammed shut in their faces?”
Funny that. That was in 2005. It may as well have been 2014. I wrote further noting that this angst was being directed at officials who were elected by popular vote to represent the Filipino people (dispensing of blockquoting as I plagiarise myself anyway)…
* * *
Who votes disobedient representatives into Congress in the first place? Would a smart (or at the very least sane) person appoint a pedophile to watch over her kids? A government officiated by fools in a democracy merely reflects the fools who exercised their rights to vote to put them there. This is but another bout of this selective amnesia that Filipinos are world-renowned for. The “enlightened” wash the stupidity of the masses off their hands, proclaiming “I did not vote for those fools”. Ironic, that the very same elite who are among the most die-hard defenders of “democracy” and “free” elections would shrink away from accountability over the outcome of the very system they worship.
So what do we do? We go out and protest yet again to “to show lawmakers that there is enough support among the citizenry for an impeachment process”. Excuse us once again, but why do we get to use such pathetic channels as street protests and hollow-headed symbolic gestures (black-and-white movements and the like) to reach our “representatives” when they actually work for us and supposedly were chosen to uphold the interests of the people they represent? If Filipinos are truly serious about their outrage over the behaviour of their representatives, then the time to exhibit this outrage is in the next congressional elections. That is, of course, if any lessons will have be learned by then (consider though that old Marcos cronies and family members continue to live the good life in our islands). Rina Jimenez-David in an INQ7.net snippet more wisely left it as an open-ended question, “Where to now, indeed?”
The venerable journalist Manuel L. Quezon III blogged that:
The Philippines – Filipinos – tried to do everything by the book, they tried to do everything exactly as specified by the Constitution, they even rallied within parameters defined by that Constitution as far as the right to free speech and assembly are concerned.
We did all the procedures by the book — i.e. went through the motions — the same way the lawyer-politicians that infest our society know the Law down to the letter and can serve and execute it to the letter while altogether missing its spirit. But following procedures is not the only thing democracy is about. Democracy is also about building strong democratic institutions and making them work for us so that following procedures actually produces results. That Mr. Quezon — a seasoned “political commentator” — would hang a medal on Filipinos for “trying to do everything by the book” without highlighting the often ignored fact that that key ingredient — building strong institutions (or expecting representatives to see to this) is something we dismally fail to achieve is disturbing to say the least. It’s like building a shoddy car and expecting it to take you from A to B safely while driving it “by the book”.
Today, the very same people who pat themselves on the back for doing things “by the book” suddenly stomp their feet in protest when yet another impeachment process being run “by the book” sputters along. We, that constitute the lynch mob society that our nation is, expect a fair trial followed by a fair hangin’. Well, folks, sometimes “fair trials” yield outcomes that we don’t necessarily like. That’s by the book for you, that is, if you think being by the book is the only thing democracy is about.
And to further highlight the idea of how a nation’s leaders merely reflect their constituents, Emil Jurado in a Manila Standard Today article, makes this observation:
[…] if only to prove their infantile mentality, the opposition is even now threatening to walk ouf if the impeachment process is junked. Like children who have lost the game of marbles, the opposition have become crybabies.
Obviously and we emphasize again (as we did in a previous article), there is no concept of issues-based partisanism in the Philippines — only personalan (focus on personalities). This pretty much sums up the extent and depth of public involvement in politics — pettiness, to put it mildly. And, again, this nature of the Filipino psyche is reflected in our leaders as observed by the Sassy Lawyer in a brilliant Manila Standard Today article:
We have the entire Lower House debating an issue which is no longer about whether there is clear evidence that Gloria Arroyo did commit electoral fraud. The debate has become, quite simply, whether one is for or against Gloria Arroyo. And the media is propagating that twisted debate.
It’s the old case of our ability to work hard but not smart. We expend so much effort on inefficient vigilance — the kind that sends people to the street to topple presidents — and not on the kind of vigilance that progressively builds working systems that outlive administrations to frame future ones. Instead of working the system hard, we work hard for the system. Democracy today is costing us what we already can’t afford — most notably the triple whammy of (1) the expense and disruption involved in the whole process of electing officials to office, (2) the upkeep of their offices, and (3) the instability — and disruption — caused by these same officials’ outrageous behaviour and ethics. The prevalence of political commentary blogs shows just how focused Filipinos are on petty politics and analysing the behaviour of their politicians. And the dearth of any blogs focused on systemic change and systems approaches to change? Well that speaks even louder about what constitutes (or what does not constitute) the Filipino mind.
* * *
Again, the above was written back in 2005. History does, indeed, repeat itself. In this case, it’s the same cast of idiots applying the same moronic thinking stirring up the bedazzled mob.
- Here is how INTELLIGENT Opposition to the Duterte administration is done… - December 18, 2017
- Filipinos are poor because their “activists” teach them to be obsessed with the rich - December 17, 2017
- Why did Isabelle Duterte have a photoshoot in Malacanang Palace? Because she can. - December 17, 2017
- Noynoy Aquino lauded for merely showing up at Congress inquiry on Dengvaxia - December 15, 2017
- Martial Law “debate”: Does the Constitution serve Filipinos? Or do Filipinos serve the Constitution? - December 13, 2017