Kabadingan and kalaswaan in Philippine cinema

Roughly translated in English and taken out outside of the context of homosexuality that it is commonly associated with, the Tagalog colloquial word kabadingan in a cultural sense is a contemporary concept that describes a spectacle of loud contrived crassness or obnoxiousness in both behaviour, design, and aesthetic sensibilities that is indulged in for its entertainment (attention-grabbing) value. The Tagalog word kalaswaan, for its part, goes back in history a bit longer and refers to a spectrum of unsavory sensibilities ranging from unwholesome at its better end, to smuttiness at its worst end.

Why do I use the two words in the same phrase as Philippine cinema? To answer that I defer to two pieces of insight that I cite in my book:

Isagani Cruz on the state of the Philippine entertainment industry in an Inquirer.net editorial dated 16 June 2006:

Benjamin Franklin said that if the people misuse their suffrages, the remedy is not to withdraw the precious privilege from them but to teach them in its proper use. The entertainment industry, which has the most available access to the [Filipino] people through the movies, television, radio and the tabloids, is instead purposely miseducating them.

The Philippine entertainment industry is not only a vast wasteland, as television has been described in America, but a vicious instrument for the abatement of the nation’s intelligence. The shows it offers for the supposed recreation of the people are generally vulgar and smutty, usually with some little moral lesson inserted to make them look respectable, but offensive nonetheless. On the whole, they are obnoxious and unwholesome and deserve to be trashed.

[The above snippet is also quoted in a Film Academy of the Philippines website article here.]

University of the Philippines sociology professor Michael Tan commenting on the occasion of the Sixth International congress on AIDS in Asia and the Pacific held in Melbourne, Australia from the 5th to the 10th October 2001 cited by Diana Mendoza in her article “Between Sensationalism and Censure” (Philippine Journalism Review, April 2002, pages 35-37):

Commenting if the Philippines could be at the forefront of education on sex and sexuality Tan said no, because “media have very sensational coverage but they still have this patina of moralism which is strange.” He said this brims over to the film industry that churns out movies carrying the “crime and punishment” theme — for instance, movies with pots of adultery that run steamy sex scenes but which towards the end, mandate that the adulterer, who is always the female, gets shot or imprisoned.

“With these endings, movies become a morality play after two hours of titillation,” he said.

[…]

Tan said Filipino movies also carry the “crime and redemption” theme, in which a sex worker eventually realizes there is a better life outside prostitution, but only after the audience [have] been treated to several sexual episodes.

So are Messrs Tan and Cruz being fair in their assessment of the Philippines’ entertainment industry — in particular its film industry? Am I, myself, justified in making a generalisation that the collective products of the Philippine film industry are, in fact, malaswa and filled with the kabadingan that many point out has come to be the signature character of the industry?

Harsh questions perhaps, but the obvious answer happens to be a subjective take on the matter that I happen to agree with. A friend of mine quipped, “Why can’t indie film focus on good story telling?”. To me, it seems that in the subset of Philippine cinema that tries to pass off as serious artistic stuff, the race is not for the telling of the best story but for who encroaches the furthest into the rapidly shrinking let-not-go-there zone. Over the last several decades, that zone lost territory to the race first with its coverage of nudity, then on-screen copulation, then gay sex scenes. Pretty soon, the indie film industry, perhaps under the banner of it being indie and, being considered so, licensed to be “artistic” will breach a milestone that will make it qualified for the distinction of being compliant with Rule Number 34.

If you gotta make a movie with sexual themes, why does it have to be malaswa? Sex is obviously no longer taboo in Philippine society and one can weave a story around sex that does not have the trademark morality dose and peeling-of-the-taboo-onion thematic structure that consumes precious minutes in many Filipino movies. I have yet to see a Filipino movie containing sexual themes where the sexual themes are merely incidental to (rather than the main point of) the message or its value proposition to the audience.

If it isn’t sex that these film producers are trying to use to appeal to our sensibilities with, it is “social relevance”. Another friend of mine made what I thought was a very insightful observation that “local indie film makers are superficially focused on having something socially relevant to say. It takes effort to watch their movies. It’s like you are watching a symposium”. Ouch! As such, I beg to differ with Ilda’s viewpoint slightly. Perhaps Filipino films do make me think — of things that really entertain me. And the minority that at least try to make me think of serious — less really entertaining stuff — do so in a way that makes the experience just a notch above a visit to the dentist. Last I heard, it is possible to be both socially relevant and tell a good story while you are at it. But then that takes creativity.

Mainstream Philippine cinema obviously reflects the character of the greater part of the society that forms its audience base — an audience that gleefully laps up kabadingan and kalaswaan. The market that supposedly “serious” film makers are gunning for, on the other hand, is a sophisticated one with well-rounded tastes. As such social relevance or sex alone will not necessarily be a strong enough come-on for these folk — there is already enough of that baked into good story-telling in the global library of content — both mainstream and eclectic — that they draw upon for their viewing pleasure. This means that serious Filipino film makers will have to compete at that level — at world-class levels — to reach their target audience. Being “better” than mainstream Filipino movies is not good enough. You have to be good in absolute terms.

print

Post Author: benign0

benign0 is the Webmaster of GetRealPhilippines.com.

Leave a Reply

76 Comments on "Kabadingan and kalaswaan in Philippine cinema"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Peste
Guest
I just want some clarification on what you mean by Pretty soon, the indie film industry, perhaps under the banner of it being indie and, being considered so, licensed to be “artistic” will breach a milestone that will make it qualified for the distinction of being compliant with Rule Number 34. Since Rule 34 states that “if it exists, there’s porn of it” then do you expect the indie films to eventually make porn of existing Filipino cultural icons, traditional or popular? Or do you mean the indie films reach a level of “existence” such that the more perverted fans… Read more »
Hyden Toro
Guest

A Filipino movie story, never has the ingridient of: a wholesome, educational and entertaining story. If the actors are not laughing. They are crying and bawling, for some stupid reasons. There are shoutings…Obsene languages, sexual encounters: man to man, woman and man, woman with woman. I have never seen it yet: man with beast….maybe that will be day. The movie industry has already deteriorated to the sewer level…It has no foreign competition…so the movie producers can just make trash movies. And you are forced, to go to see it. They take your money, without a sweat. It’s like highway robbery…

Mike
Guest

How exactly are you “forced to go see it”?

Lightzout
Guest

I remember the Palace officials ‘urging’ Filipinos to watch MMFF.

Hyden Toro
Guest

People are forced to see these movies…because there are no other good movies showing…

brianitus
Guest

The choice is NOT to see a movie. Forced to watch a movie? Unless drags you to the cinema and someone straps you on to the seats, no one can be forced.

jenna
Guest

i agree!

thelongfallofprose
Guest

Also noticeable to Philippine movies are their craptastic cinematography and poor production work, even in the so-called award-winning ones.

grovey
Guest

No matter how much trolling you do, benignO, you will never reach the heights of what my dear Ilda’s article achieved. Not with your incessant quoting & plugging of your miserable book. Preace bo!

bechay
Guest

philippine movies are written to showcase an actor’s ability to look good onscreen. there’s no talent requirement for the actors, and neither is there an IQ requirement for the audience. even those with abysmal intellect can grasp what the film is all about!

is a philippine movie worth wasting your hard-earned cash on? HARDLY. i wouldn’t support that industry as all it does is churn out mediocre actors and lousy politicians. it’s bad for the nation’s health.

alconce
Guest

So true.

jenna
Guest

I’m just sick of all the gays in Philippine Cinema. and people wonder why every other man is turning gay. It’s because it all boils down to Psychologys Nature Vs. Nurture issue. If the enviroment consists of all shallow,homosexual influences, primarily in Philippine television and cinema. (talk shows,game shows,teleseryes, etc.) Have we ever seen a gay News Reporter, or a gay crossdresser doing hard hitting journalism?? I don’t think so, and why you may ask? Well, I think we all know the answer. All they are good for is cheap jokes and cheap laughs.

N. Stadther
Guest

So true! Filipino movies are crap! I was invited once to a premiere and I was sitting right beside the director (i can’t even recall the title) and the first 10 minutes had already put me to sleep. I guess the director got the meaning.
Its mere movie trailers and titles alone are already a turn off.
Our movie world and politics go hand in hand in the land of going nowhere! So so sad!

thebaklareview
Guest
The date of the quoted article is crucial. Mr. Tan wrote it in 2002, poised between the ruckus caused by the banning of the film “Live Show” (2000) and the release of Cris Pablo’s “Duda” (2003), the seminal gay film that paved the way for making digital movies accessible. So Mr. Tan was likely referring to the sex movies of the period (called TF or Titillating Films) that were produced most famously by outfits like Seiko, Viva, and Regal — all considered mainstream studios at the time. They were almost always heterosexual in nature, with the odd lesbian or gay… Read more »
SalingKetket
Guest

Grabe! ang dami na palang Gay Films…
pwede po bang gumawa naman kayo ng ibang movies na walang kabaklaan 🙂
Peace!

thebaklareview
Guest

Mas marami ang hindi gay films sa gay films.

bp
Guest

Just saw The King’s Speech last night. Great film.

Ilda
Admin

I love that film. I love Colin Firth. I wonder when our filmmakers going to do a movie about the Philippine oligarchs and their influence in politics?

Aidz
Guest
Politics like among any other fields, is both art and science. People that are into politics should have influences (be it someone or an event), basis why they are doing it, and not the “because money is good” crap answer. Politicians aren’t born to be crooks and to be in politics, they definitely have thought of changing the world in a very positive way especially when they were young. Since we Filipinos like talking about lives of popular people, why not the media talk about their political influences, their real life-changing experience that made them pursue to change the world… Read more »
Joseph
Guest

nakakatawa naman yung mga insights mo. lahat ng mga nakikita mong Philippine movies puro kabadingan at kalaswaan hindi mo nakukuha yung mensahe.

nakakapagtaka din na simula nung lumabas at kumuha ng attensiyon ng mga movie enthusiasts, critics, film makers yung isa pang artikulo dito e biglang nilabas mo yung “Filipino Indie Film Makers need to stop whining and step up” at ngayon ito. nakakapagtaka lang :))

Dr. Acula
Guest

Ang papangit naman talaga ng mga philippine movies.. Mula sa mga entries ng MMFF hangang sa mga so called indie films… most of the time walang ka kwenta kwenta ang tema.. san kaya grumaduate ang mga script writers nila.. Duhhhh

Combuzz
Guest

can someone tell me why the mouths don’t move with the voices in filipino movies? and why the sound is so muffled, why is there no echo when people are talking and walking down a hallway?

Are they too cheap to use microphones, so they decide to just dubb the voices over?

thebaklareview
Guest
ADR, or dubbing, is the norm. Even in Hollywood, a certain (usually large) percentage of an entire movie is dubbed. But yes, microphones are used for live recording during shoots, and that’s also standard practice. In the final product, a Filipino movie can have a mix of both live and ADR, but many studio films are dubbed 100%. If the quality of sound in Filipino films you saw is not satisfactory, that’s usually because of rushed audio post-production — not because we don’t have the equipment or the talent — which is a result of studios always rushing (not alotting… Read more »
bistado
Guest

ang gara ng article, pang bulletin today!

Yappie
Guest

pang Tiktik kamo.

DaidoKatsumi
Guest

Mas malala pa sa Tiktik ang Inquirer. Itaga mo iyan sa bato.

Dr. Acula
Guest

gumawa nga kayo ng sarili nyong article at tignan natin ang galing nyo..

bistado
Guest

pang bulletin today, sunday classifieds. laos at mababaw. gusto lang bumenta.

DaidoKatsumi
Guest

Please show us proof na most of the people here ay binabayaran.

Yellow Zombie ka kasi kaya mo nasasabi iyan. Baka IKAW ang mababaw? 🙂

Felipe
Guest

@bistado and Yappie
Hahaha…grabe naman crab mentality niyo!

Yappie
Guest

Mas grabe ang crab mentality ng mga nagususulat sa Get Real Philippines. At ng mga sumusuporta sa website na ito. Hindi ba?

DaidoKatsumi
Guest

Tol, crab mentality is for CRAB PEOPLE. Tandaan mo iyan.

Anti-Yappie
Guest

Ay nasaktan ang crab na si Yappie (natamaan siya ng artikulo, aminin…) Hamo, iluluto ka namin mamaya kasama taba mo para may silbi naman ang buhay mo. Sarap yata ng chili crab.

Dr. Acula
Guest

hindi naman crab mentality ang tawag jan e.. sila ay mga critics na mahilig magbasa ng mga tabloids hehehehe..

ChinoF
Member

Hopefully the gays understand that we’re not condemning them. It’s the flamboyant and ridiculous representation of gay culture in the movies that perhaps needs to be condemned. Thanks to this kind of over-exposure, some foreigners may believe that half the Filipino male population is gay, and competent male culture may be on the decline.

jenna
Guest

Good Point ChinoF! My fiance is American and he honest to goodness, thinks almost all the guys here are gay!

palebrowndot
Guest

oh well…you do not just see kalaswaan and kabadingan in films. you get to experience them too in classrooms. so they do not just show kabadingan and kalaswaan in films, they teach them too. that’s why its scary to be with filipino men nowadays; if they are not tamad and mama’s boy, they are bakla eeew…

Trosp
Guest

I might be OT but this one is interesting –

Snippet:

“The depravity of our popular culture and our eagerness to shred traditional values manifests itself every day. Lady Gaga, the top-earning woman in the music business and deemed by ABCs Barbara Walters to be one of the “most fascinating people,” has a new vocation in mind. She’s announced she wants to become an ordained minister of the Universal Life Church so she can marry two gay male friends.”

http://townhall.com/columnists/brentbozell/2011/12/23/cultural_winners_and_losers_2011

jenna
Guest

What a travesty! In my opinion,2 gay males or females should in no circumstance be allowed to be married. (Under religious circumstances)As harsh as it may sound to those attempting to lead or live in a more “modern” lifestyle. Have we forgotten our old values and tradition in marrying because of love and the intent to reproduce children? Lady Gaga is aiming a little too high there.

Trosp
Guest

Only on the secular liberal world – those politically correct blokes!

It’s not farfetched that eventually, they will also fight for the right of a brother to sister or sister to sister or brother to brother or son to mother etc. marriages!

Or man with a beast!

Trosp
Guest
One example of how their minds work – http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/massachusetts-passes-bill-making-transgenderism-crossdressers-a-protected-c Snippet – “BOSTON, November 17, 2011 (LifeSiteNews.com) – The Massachusetts legislature has passed a bill that elevates cross-dressing or transgendered individuals to a protected class, and grants universal access to sex-segregated areas such as bathrooms based on personal “gender identity or expression.” The measure, known as the “Transgender Equal Rights Bill” (H. 502 in the House and S. 764 in the Senate) passed the upper chamber on Wednesday in a voice vote. It’s unclear when the bill will receive final approval votes and be signed into law by Democrat Gov. Deval… Read more »
NagtatanongLang
Guest

Manong nakakatakot ka. Parang ang daming galit ang laman ng dibdib mo. Nakakalungkot na marami pa ring mga taong tulad mong mag-isip sa mundo. Rasista!

Roberto Reyes Ang
Guest
What is “kabadingan” and what is “kalaswaan”? And why I think the author of this article has some “kakulangan?” The problem with this article is that the writer failed to explain that “kabadingan,” as a cultural concept, is not the same as homosexuality per se. (Or at least I would like to assume that he knows that already). While he explains that “kabadingan” describes a spectacle of loud contrived crassness or obnoxiousness in both behaviour, design, and aesthetic sensibilities that is indulged in for its entertainment (attention-grabbing) value, he failed to point out that not all homosexuals are loud and… Read more »
purplee
Guest

nag-iinit ulo ko kakabasa ng mga sulatin nagmamatalinong-know it all pseudo intelligent whiners, este writers. gusto ko naman yung mga ibang sinusulat nila tungkol sa bansa pero pagdating sa philippine cinema, hindi ko mapilit ang sarili kong umagr…ee sa kanila. ayaw talaga magpatalo kahit pinapakita na nga na hindi tama yung pinagsasasabi nila. NAKAKAIRITA. hindi na ako magbabasa ng post tungkol sa subject na ito mula sa site na ito.

MGA PINAGSASASABI MO DITO BENIGNO = FALLACY OF COMPOSITION.

Trosp
Guest

Ano ba ang aya mo? Di mo naman sinasabi. Ano ba ang nakairita sa iyo? Kamot-ulo kaming mga comment readers dito kung ano talaga ang problema mo sa post.

Politically correct ka rin ba?

grovey
Guest

@Trosp: just to help you, naka BOLD ang sagot sa iyong katanungan… chos sister!

Trosp
Guest

@ grovey

Ito ba yung naka bold na sinasabi mo:

“MGA PINAGSASASABI MO DITO BENIGNO = FALLACY OF COMPOSITION.”

Are you hallucinating or you’re just a plain stupid dude or both. What is the fallacy or what are the fallacies?

Steel Night
Guest

There is no longer – more or less – anything creative or imaginative or innovative in the entertainment industry. The road less traveled has ceased to exist. The easy way to make a buck or piso is what is chosen more often than not, which is just a fancier way of saying always.
Kabadingan and kalaswaan sells. Kabadingan for comedy, most of the time, and kalaswaan just because nowhere in this forsaken planet can be found a place where sex does not sell.

Waldo
Guest

How about evaluating what causes these quality of work we have now? Won’t you say it’s because we have audiences that are easily pleased? That they would patronize the lamest movies just to see their favorite actors? Improve the standards of these people and you will get the results you want.

REY-AN
Guest
First and foremost, I think this article is full of shit… Hypocritical, insecure, and homophobic… Please lang po, be careful in using the word “kabadingan” cause it doesn’t make you in any way more “macho” in this patriarchal society… I painstakingly read your article hoping for a miracle but it turned out to be as what I have expected full of nonsense… The issue on sex, isn’t it a fact that people are doing it? Unless madre o pari ka, cguro pwede pa, pero lahat, in one way or another, experience lust and all kinds of sin, and only hypocrites… Read more »
Dick S. O'Rosary
Guest

I’d paraphrase your comment as “don’t judge people, gays have a right to be proud” Proudly gay, proudly showbiz!

REY-AN
Guest

what exactly are u trying to say?

domo
Guest

Awww is “kabadingan” a holy word for you religiot?

wpDiscuz